Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4200282365> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4200282365 abstract "Abstract Objectives To assess the quantity and quality of studies using an observational measure of behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic, and to narratively describe the association between self-report and observational data for behaviours relevant to controlling an infectious disease outbreak. Design Systematic review and narrative synthesis of observational studies. Data sources We searched Medline, Embase, PsychInfo, Publons, Scopus and the Public Health England behavioural science LitRep database from inception to 17 th September 2021 for relevant studies. Study selection We included studies which collected observational data of at least one of three health protective behaviours (hand hygiene, face covering use and maintaining physical distance from others (‘social distancing’)) during the COVID-19 pandemic. Studies where observational data were compared to self-report data in relation to any infectious disease were also included. Data extraction and synthesis We evaluated the quality of studies using the NIH quality assessment scale for observational studies, extracted data on sample size, setting and adherence to health protective behaviours, and synthesized results narratively. Results Of 27,279 published papers on COVID-19 relevant health protective behaviours that included one or more terms relating to hand hygiene, face covering and social distancing, we identified 48 studies that included an objective observational measure. Of these, 35 assessed face covering use, 17 assessed hand hygiene behaviour and seven assessed physical distancing. The general quality of these studies was good. When expanding the search to all infectious diseases, we included 21 studies that compared observational versus self-report data. These almost exclusively studied hand hygiene. The difference in outcomes was striking, with self-report over-estimating observed adherence by up to a factor of five in some settings. In only four papers did self-report match observational data in any domains. Conclusions Despite their importance in controlling the pandemic, we found remarkably few studies assessing protective behaviours by observation, rather than self-report, though these studies tended to be of reasonably good quality. Observed adherence tends to be substantially lower than estimates obtained via self-report. Accurate assessment of levels of personal protective behaviour, and evaluation of interventions to increase this, would benefit from the use of observational methods." @default.
- W4200282365 created "2021-12-31" @default.
- W4200282365 creator A5013774737 @default.
- W4200282365 creator A5022166071 @default.
- W4200282365 creator A5066823344 @default.
- W4200282365 creator A5068277529 @default.
- W4200282365 creator A5089523864 @default.
- W4200282365 date "2021-12-23" @default.
- W4200282365 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W4200282365 title "A systematic review of observational methods used to quantify personal protective behaviours among members of the public during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the concordance between observational and self-report measures in infectious disease health protection" @default.
- W4200282365 cites W1967795835 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W1977027027 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W1985051328 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2002031172 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2014606446 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2021251986 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2023302002 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2044539696 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2074311786 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2093251557 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2094206758 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2094294759 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2118409616 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2131589519 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2538699215 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2901705719 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2906220457 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2907085673 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2913517898 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W2915502781 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3031494555 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3033965177 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3035914882 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3042151570 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3042685397 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3043448783 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3043529077 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3046057866 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3046910880 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3048558970 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3069139880 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3085119307 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3086697928 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3087506912 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3091686794 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3092100730 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3092832410 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3094295301 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3094882579 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3099076575 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3102235011 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3105897232 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3105923972 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3109424351 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3110357154 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3111656551 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3111910767 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3115008614 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3117952581 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3118268340 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3118521972 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3121385737 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3121403010 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3121560191 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3122148256 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3124649131 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3124787721 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3126992264 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3127459163 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3129577917 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3133008925 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3134565408 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3138558258 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3141431527 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3144066845 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3151120428 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3152715590 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3153032461 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3155293333 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3156596112 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3158613719 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3159363584 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3159705840 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3178506526 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3180406141 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3194429924 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W3194979612 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W4214757813 @default.
- W4200282365 cites W788905565 @default.
- W4200282365 doi "https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.22.21268226" @default.
- W4200282365 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
- W4200282365 type Work @default.
- W4200282365 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4200282365 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W4200282365 hasAuthorship W4200282365A5013774737 @default.
- W4200282365 hasAuthorship W4200282365A5022166071 @default.
- W4200282365 hasAuthorship W4200282365A5066823344 @default.
- W4200282365 hasAuthorship W4200282365A5068277529 @default.
- W4200282365 hasAuthorship W4200282365A5089523864 @default.
- W4200282365 hasBestOaLocation W42002823651 @default.