Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4214868049> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4214868049 endingPage "38" @default.
- W4214868049 startingPage "7" @default.
- W4214868049 abstract "The genus Morchella has gone through turbulent taxonomic treatments. Although significant progress in Morchella systematics has been achieved in the past decade, several problems remain unresolved and taxonomy in the genus is still in flux. In late 2019, a paper published in the open-access journal Scientific Reports raised serious concerns about the taxonomic stability of the genus, but also about the future of academic publishing. The paper, entitled “High diversity of Morchella and a novel lineage of the esculenta clade from the north Qinling Mountains revealed by GCPSR-based study” by Phanpadith and colleagues, suffered from gross methodological errors, included false results and artifactual phylogenies, had misapplied citations throughout, and proposed a new species name invalidly. Although the paper was eventually retracted by Scientific Reports in 2021, the fact that such an overtly flawed and scientifically unsound paper was published in a high-ranked Q1 journal raises alarming questions about quality controls and safekeeping procedures in scholarly publishing. Using this paper as a case study, we provide a critical review on the pitfalls of Morchella systematics followed by a series of recommendations for the delimitation of species, description of taxa, and ultimately for a sustainable taxonomy in Morchella. Problems and loopholes in the academic publishing system are also identified and discussed, and additional quality controls in the pre- and post-publication stages are proposed." @default.
- W4214868049 created "2022-03-05" @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5003246904 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5003506110 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5004920091 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5008582736 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5010605777 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5014595870 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5015800548 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5017787580 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5018912278 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5021806076 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5023340512 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5037924957 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5041579310 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5045738277 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5048682606 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5050104617 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5053313701 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5054323606 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5055743526 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5056734143 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5057822431 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5058128822 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5058983769 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5060520587 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5062567443 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5063035817 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5064573174 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5068975871 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5069161651 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5069387587 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5071232542 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5071778852 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5078555411 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5087028793 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5087423795 @default.
- W4214868049 creator A5088196960 @default.
- W4214868049 date "2022-01-01" @default.
- W4214868049 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W4214868049 title "Has taxonomic vandalism gone too far? A case study, the rise of the pay-to-publish model and the pitfalls of Morchella systematics" @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1572277998 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1811692090 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1842727300 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1882040706 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1892668762 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1949176574 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1963999629 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1964138333 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1966784801 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1973252230 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1973914910 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1980403948 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1981605522 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1983985796 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1986910503 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1988203999 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1989722422 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1989809742 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1991287931 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1993679825 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W1999850428 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2001141369 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2002822731 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2003879785 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2004477458 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2004568303 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2011534083 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2014682072 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2015590378 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2031637941 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2036028416 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2058770789 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2059504724 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2060529812 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2060945611 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2061146896 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2074178499 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2080057022 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2083245751 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2083318411 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2088138371 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2089547988 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2096486271 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2099319004 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2108177382 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2109790809 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2111414304 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2121461269 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2123849235 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2125061007 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2125629648 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2127586651 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2130984115 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2135069367 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2135967068 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2137912119 @default.
- W4214868049 cites W2138012030 @default.