Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4220784679> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4220784679 abstract "Abstract Single‐column models (SCMs) simulations are sometimes used to evaluate model physics and aid parameterization development. However, few studies have systematically compared SCM behavior—where column boundary conditions are specified—with that of corresponding 3D models, where columns interact dynamically. Here we address this by comparing forced responses of an SCM in radiative‐convective equilibrium (RCE) with those of a multi‐column model (MCM) where the model domain is in RCE but individual columns are not, examining what factors affect the models' comparability. We find that convective organization in the MCM depends at least as much on the convection scheme as on other mechanisms known to organize convection (e.g., radiative feedback). Moreover, convective organization emerges as a robust factor affecting SCM–MCM comparability, with more aggregated states in 3D associated with larger behavior deviations from the 1D counterpart. This is found across five convection schemes and applies to simulated mean states, linear responses to small tendency perturbations, and adjustments to doubled‐CO 2 forcing. Nevertheless, we find that even when convection is organized, behavior differences between pairs of schemes in the SCM are largely preserved in the MCM. This indicates that when model physics produces accurate behavior in a 1D setup, it will be more likely to do so in a 3D setup. However, our idealized RCE framework implies that these conclusions may not apply to situations with strong large‐scale forcing or encountered over land. Lastly, we demonstrate the practical value of linear responses by showing that they can accurately predict an SCM's tropospheric adjustment to doubled‐CO 2 forcing." @default.
- W4220784679 created "2022-04-03" @default.
- W4220784679 creator A5010239406 @default.
- W4220784679 creator A5018227404 @default.
- W4220784679 creator A5051942539 @default.
- W4220784679 date "2022-04-01" @default.
- W4220784679 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W4220784679 title "Can We Use 1D Models to Predict 3D Model Response to Forcing in an Idealized Framework?" @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1493454197 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1535485070 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1592803384 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1603762516 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1892644665 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1949222904 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1966421922 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1967429906 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1971280275 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1972423646 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1978055572 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1979541009 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1982288271 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1987238719 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1995277897 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W1995483742 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2003819578 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2004327451 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2009074883 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2009247415 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2011725596 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2015382055 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2018166027 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2019501263 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2020007825 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2025051238 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2028979275 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2033588971 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2035683766 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2054174841 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2056903736 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2058820078 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2062050836 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2062310155 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2063091265 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2066433058 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2069888364 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2072658752 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2076655803 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2076889575 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2079616342 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2083693168 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2096799090 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2099604502 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2105503137 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2107704010 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2110179017 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2113967386 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2119621743 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2120096119 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2124786495 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2125549533 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2129290197 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2130403694 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2134962195 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2135036497 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2138034982 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2138820290 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2139268105 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2142209258 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2142662142 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2142685184 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2142794782 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2145059590 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2146540372 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2154489866 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2156618689 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2161103622 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2161630855 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2164201361 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2165003737 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2174335611 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2174617705 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2176064767 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2178266578 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2180596393 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2193503481 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2198403628 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2224869805 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2282847346 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2287335423 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2397156947 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2466532889 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2511409590 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2523014656 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2541605804 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2569712288 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2583685045 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2604938239 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2606260864 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2610448000 @default.
- W4220784679 cites W2620513537 @default.