Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4224293859> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4224293859 abstract "Abstract Stable isotope analysis is increasingly being used to assess diet and trophic positions of animals. Such assessments require estimates of trophic discrimination factors (TDFs)—offset between the isotopic composition of diet and animal tissues—with imprecise applications of TDFs leading to biased conclusions in resource use. Because TDFs are unavailable for most species, ecologists often apply values from taxonomically similar species or use trophic step increases of approximately 1‰ for carbon (TDF‐δ 13 C) and 3‰ for nitrogen (TDF‐δ 15 N). Such practices may yield inaccuracies since TDFs vary greatly, even within a species. To better understand the factors that influence TDFs, we conducted a meta‐analysis of TDF‐δ 13 C and TDF‐δ 15 N for mammals and quantified variation in relation to consumer type (herbivore, omnivore, carnivore) and diet source (C 3 ‐based, C 4 ‐based, marine‐based, mixture). Additionally, to guide TDF choice, we used an isotopic data set of small mammal tissues and diet items to assess how predicted dietary contributions vary with TDFs estimated using (1) taxonomic relatedness, (2) consumer type and diet source, or (3) values derived from wild animals eating natural diets. Our meta‐analysis revealed that metabolic routing and interactions between consumer class, dietary source, and the protein versus energy content of diets best explained variation in TDF‐δ 13 C values (−1.5‰ to 7.3‰), whereas consumer class best explained variation in TDF‐δ 15 N values (−0.5‰ to 7.1‰). Our test of methods to estimate TDFs indicated that ecologists should avoid relying on taxonomic relatedness when selecting TDF‐δ 13 C because mixed‐diet lab studies may produce misleading results for herbivores and omnivores. Additionally, field‐derived estimates could help fill TDF gaps where diets within a consumer class are absent. Overall, we suggest that using standard TDF trophic step values should be abandoned, because feeding studies are often poor proxies for natural diets, particularly for herbivores and omnivores. Instead, we make recommendations on how to select TDFs, along with a range of TDF‐δ 13 C and TDF‐δ 15 N values depending on diet source, consumer class, and tissue type. Use of these more refined recommendations and TDF values in isotopic assessments will improve estimates of diets and trophic interactions in natural systems, leading to a better understanding of ecological interactions and communities." @default.
- W4224293859 created "2022-04-26" @default.
- W4224293859 creator A5004128730 @default.
- W4224293859 creator A5011554216 @default.
- W4224293859 creator A5026033836 @default.
- W4224293859 creator A5082270152 @default.
- W4224293859 date "2022-05-23" @default.
- W4224293859 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W4224293859 title "Reevaluating trophic discrimination factors (<scp>Δδ<sup>13</sup>C</scp> and <scp>Δδ<sup>15</sup>N</scp>) for diet reconstruction" @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1543339592 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1723747715 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1856903104 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1907818577 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1967076364 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1971217334 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1984845008 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1994785855 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W1996116945 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2011423887 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2013155971 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2017399838 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2028056867 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2037783193 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2056153447 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2063339845 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2068002500 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2081604939 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2085079971 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2091552516 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2093829619 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2098164551 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2098256919 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2100889587 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2102315483 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2106951737 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2107449137 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2113023092 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2124118547 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2124769244 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2136703725 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2137547108 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2138500205 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2141505056 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2143804637 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2146912561 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2153297504 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2155009193 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2155444734 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2158405444 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2159250264 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2166477196 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2169121204 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2169927844 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2170094128 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2287055840 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2584437083 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2593422125 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2605366741 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2613257636 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2625311318 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2767824782 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2791226042 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2794549961 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2960691627 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2969463805 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2979410915 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2983606184 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W2998894507 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3010314351 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3035904563 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3081656093 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3091339113 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3129837273 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3169946984 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W3206338090 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W4237523714 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W4255743098 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W4376849491 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W620492482 @default.
- W4224293859 cites W66734501 @default.
- W4224293859 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.1525" @default.
- W4224293859 hasPublicationYear "2022" @default.
- W4224293859 type Work @default.
- W4224293859 citedByCount "12" @default.
- W4224293859 countsByYear W42242938592022 @default.
- W4224293859 countsByYear W42242938592023 @default.
- W4224293859 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4224293859 hasAuthorship W4224293859A5004128730 @default.
- W4224293859 hasAuthorship W4224293859A5011554216 @default.
- W4224293859 hasAuthorship W4224293859A5026033836 @default.
- W4224293859 hasAuthorship W4224293859A5082270152 @default.
- W4224293859 hasBestOaLocation W42242938591 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C11796040 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C156398188 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C163528473 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C188382862 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C22117777 @default.
- W4224293859 hasConcept C2780401108 @default.