Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4226323824> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4226323824 abstract "Background Cannulation techniques have been recognized as being important in causing post‐endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) pancreatitis (PEP). However, considerable controversy exists about the usefulness of the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique for the prevention of PEP. Objectives To assess the effectiveness and safety of the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique compared to the conventional contrast‐assisted cannulation technique for the prevention of PEP in people undergoing diagnostic or therapeutic ERCP for biliary or pancreatic diseases. Search methods For the previous version of this review, we searched CENTRAL (the Cochrane Library), MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL and major conference proceedings, up to February 2012, with no language restrictions. An updated search was performed on 26 February 2021 for the current version of this review. Two clinical trial registries, clinicaltrials.gov and WHO ICTRP, were also searched in this update. Selection criteria Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique versus the contrast‐assisted cannulation technique in people undergoing ERCP. Data collection and analysis Two review authors conducted study selection, data extraction, and methodological quality assessment independently. Using intention‐to‐treat analysis with random‐effects models, we combined dichotomous data to obtain risk ratios (RR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). We assessed heterogeneity using the Chi² test (P < 0.10) and I² statistic (> 50%). To explore sources of heterogeneity, we conducted a priori subgroup analyses according to trial design, publication type, risk of bias, use of precut sphincterotomy, inadvertent guidewire insertion or contrast injection of the pancreatic duct (PD), use of a PD stent, cannulation device, and trainee involvement in cannulation. To assess the robustness of our results, we carried out sensitivity analyses using different summary statistics (RR versus odds ratio (OR)) and meta‐analytic models (fixed‐effect versus random‐effects) and per‐protocol analysis. Main results 15 RCTs comprising 4426 participants were included. There was moderate heterogeneity among trials for the outcome of PEP (P = 0.08, I² = 36%). Meta‐analyses suggest that the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique probably reduces the risk of PEP compared to the contrast‐assisted cannulation technique (RR 0.51, 95% CI 0.36 to 0.72, 15 studies, moderate‐certainty evidence). In addition, the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique may result in an increase in primary cannulation success (RR 1.06, 95% CI 1.01 to 1.12, 13 studies, low‐certainty evidence), and probably reduces the need for precut sphincterotomy (RR 0.79, 95% CI 0.64 to 0.96, 10 studies, moderate‐certainty evidence). Compared to the contrast‐assisted cannulation technique, the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique may result in little to no difference in the risk of post‐sphincterotomy bleeding (RR 0.87, 95% CI 0.49 to 1.54, 7 studies, low‐certainty evidence) and perforation (RR 0.93, 95% CI 0.11 to 8.23, 8 studies, very low‐certainty evidence). Procedure‐related mortality was reported by eight studies, and there were no cases of deaths in both arms (moderate‐certainty evidence). Subgroup analyses suggest that the heterogeneity for the outcome of PEP could be explained by differences in trial design. The results were robust in sensitivity analyses. Authors' conclusions There is moderate‐certainty evidence that the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique probably reduces the risk of PEP compared to the contrast‐assisted cannulation technique. There is low‐certainty evidence that the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique may result in an increase in primary cannulation success. There is low‐ and very low‐certainty evidence that the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique may result in little to no difference in the risk of bleeding and perforation. No procedure‐related deaths were reported. Therefore, the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique appears to be superior to the contrast‐assisted cannulation technique considering the certainty of evidence and the balance of benefits and harms. However, the routine use of guidewires in biliary cannulation will be dependent on local expertise, availability, and cost. Future research should assess the effectiveness and safety of the guidewire‐assisted cannulation technique in the context of other pharmacologic or non‐pharmacologic interventions for the prevention of PEP." @default.
- W4226323824 created "2022-05-05" @default.
- W4226323824 creator A5055359298 @default.
- W4226323824 creator A5056355381 @default.
- W4226323824 creator A5059333025 @default.
- W4226323824 creator A5068797509 @default.
- W4226323824 creator A5086326253 @default.
- W4226323824 date "2022-03-29" @default.
- W4226323824 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W4226323824 title "Guidewire-assisted cannulation of the common bile duct for the prevention of post-endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) pancreatitis" @default.
- W4226323824 cites W119980213 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W120854751 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W135546186 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1449306147 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1537490676 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1587424220 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W16630176 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1783517968 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1875639825 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1942664326 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1965722778 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1967246198 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1972036508 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1973483634 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1973890514 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1978963605 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1981690062 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1989502010 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1997283155 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W1999218614 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2003275646 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2009782521 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2011932878 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2014316543 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2016526647 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2017000558 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2017449390 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2017641574 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2019306355 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2024010127 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2024974112 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2028838151 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2030198764 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2030780868 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2032999505 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2033960341 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2034862228 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2035387178 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2038728206 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2039418122 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W204046373 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2040766195 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2041522924 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2041619286 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2043813971 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2046908698 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2053830957 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2055609492 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2057021257 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2060013768 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2062247269 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2064833401 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2067256935 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2070256361 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2074790755 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2076293756 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2076324814 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2076482751 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2077699254 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2078079854 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2084942665 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2085546839 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2085898618 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2086584298 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2086760765 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2087220456 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2091820204 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2095960325 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2096834187 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2098228038 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2100650200 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2102131509 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2110430551 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2111780372 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2112339576 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2114624342 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2114910812 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2117294447 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2120569951 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2124984664 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2126194308 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2129875497 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2131105149 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2134236426 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2134338262 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2135956606 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2140560495 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2145758369 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2151868795 @default.
- W4226323824 cites W2154861874 @default.