Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4232619078> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4232619078 abstract "Background Implant overdentures are one of the most common treatment options used to rehabilitate edentulous patients. Attachment systems are used to anchor the overdentures to implants. The plethora of attachment systems available dictates a need for clinicians to understand their prosthodontic and patient‐related outcomes. Objectives To compare different attachment systems for maxillary and mandibular implant overdentures by assessing prosthodontic success, prosthodontic maintenance, patient preference, patient satisfaction/quality of life and costs. Search methods Cochrane Oral Health's Information Specialist searched the following databases: Cochrane Oral Health's Trials Register (to 24 January 2018); Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL; 2017, Issue 12) in the Cochrane Library (searched 24 January 2018); MEDLINE Ovid (1946 to 24 January 2018); and Embase Ovid (1980 to 24 January 2018). The US National Institutes of Health Trials Registry (ClinicalTrials.gov) and the World Health Organization International Clinical Trials Registry Platform were searched for ongoing trials on 24 January 2018. No restrictions were placed on the language or date of publication when searching the electronic databases. Selection criteria All randomised controlled trials (RCTs), including cross‐over trials on maxillary or mandibular implant overdentures with different attachment systems with at least 1 year follow‐up. Data collection and analysis Four review authors extracted data independently and assessed risk of bias for each included trial. Several corresponding authors were subsequently contacted to obtain missing information. Fixed‐effect meta‐analysis was used to combine the outcomes with risk ratios (RR) for dichotomous outcomes and mean differences (MD) for continuous outcomes, with 95% confidence intervals (95% CI). We used the GRADE approach to assess the quality of evidence and create 'Summary of findings' tables. Main results We identified six RCTs with a total of 294 mandibular overdentures (including one cross‐over trial). No trials on maxillary overdentures were eligible. Due to the poor reporting of the outcomes across the included trials, only limited analyses between mandibular overdenture attachment systems were possible. Comparing ball and bar attachments, upon pooling the data regarding short‐term prosthodontic success, we identified substantial heterogeneity (I2 = 97%) with inconsistency in the direction of effect, which was unexplained by clinical or methodological differences between the studies, and accordingly we did not perform meta‐analyses for this outcome. Short‐term re‐treatment (repair of attachment system) was higher with ball attachments (RR 3.11, 95% CI 1.68 to 5.75; 130 participants; 2 studies; very low‐quality evidence), and there was no difference between both attachment systems in short‐term re‐treatment (replacement of attachment system) (RR 1.18, 95% CI 0.38 to 3.71; 130 participants; 2 studies; very low‐quality evidence). It is uncertain whether there is a difference in short‐term prosthodontic success when ball attachments are compared with bar attachments. Comparing ball and magnet attachments, there was no difference between them in medium‐term prosthodontic success (RR 0.84, 95% CI 0.64 to 1.10; 69 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence), or in medium‐term re‐treatment (repair of attachment system) (RR 1.75, 95% CI 0.65 to 4.72; 69 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence). However, after 5 years, prosthodontic maintenance costs were higher when magnet attachments were used (MD ‐247.37 EUR, 95% CI ‐346.32 to ‐148.42; 69 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence). It is uncertain whether there is a difference in medium‐term prosthodontic success when ball attachments are compared with magnet attachments. One trial provided data for ball versus telescopic attachments and reported no difference in prosthodontic maintenance between the two systems in short‐term patrix replacement (RR 6.00, 95% CI 0.86 to 41.96; 22 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence), matrix activation (RR 11.00, 95% CI 0.68 to 177.72; 22 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence), matrix replacement (RR 1.75, 95% CI 0.71 to 4.31; 22 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence), or in relining of the implant overdenture (RR 2.33, 95% CI 0.81 to 6.76; 22 participants; 1 study; very low‐quality evidence). It is uncertain whether there is a difference in short‐term prosthodontic maintenance when ball attachments are compared with telescopic attachments. In the only cross‐over trial included, patient preference between different attachment systems was assessed after only 3 months and not for the entire trial period of 10 years. Authors' conclusions For mandibular overdentures, there is insufficient evidence to determine the relative effectiveness of different attachment systems on prosthodontic success, prosthodontic maintenance, patient satisfaction, patient preference or costs. In the short term, there is some evidence that is insufficient to show a difference and where there was no evidence was reported. It was not possible to determine any preferred attachment system for mandibular overdentures. For maxillary overdentures, there is no evidence (with no trials identified) to determine the relative effectiveness of different attachment systems on prosthodontic success, prosthodontic maintenance, patient satisfaction, patient preference or costs. Further RCTs on edentulous cohorts must pay attention to trial design specifically using the same number of implants of the same implant system, but with different attachment systems clearly identified in control and test groups. Trials should also determine the longevity of different attachment systems and patient preferences. Trials on the current array of computer‐aided designed/computer‐assisted manufactured (CAD/CAM) bar attachment systems are encouraged." @default.
- W4232619078 created "2022-05-12" @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5004097307 @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5008304384 @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5032290718 @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5047625286 @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5048104821 @default.
- W4232619078 creator A5067775878 @default.
- W4232619078 date "2018-10-11" @default.
- W4232619078 modified "2023-10-01" @default.
- W4232619078 title "Interventions for replacing missing teeth: attachment systems for implant overdentures in edentulous jaws" @default.
- W4232619078 cites W150069783 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1501807175 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1530112597 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1554576515 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1646799590 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1753749177 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1768856786 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1795323435 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1811039433 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1916080918 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1946739770 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1958878591 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1963009152 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1966418169 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1968559946 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1973715798 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1975096652 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1980643542 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1988603353 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W1993396401 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2003276499 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2004199082 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2008271128 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2011865787 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W201280593 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2018790311 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2020086283 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2033536077 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2035913293 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2042045555 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2045816196 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2053849356 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2055322725 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2081280038 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2084457774 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2084592931 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2091692584 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2098684858 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2103929684 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2109280161 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2113334136 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2113875945 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2115279296 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2116472733 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2117694480 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2122223899 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2126562052 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2133930673 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2134467377 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2137224942 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2137745600 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2138884401 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2140795278 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2141072390 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2142348226 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2143745960 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2158014035 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2158135241 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2158349792 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2160485626 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2160558407 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2161713020 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2170578318 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2234924490 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2253594862 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2274360698 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2277915220 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W228470596 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2319494153 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2334227345 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2337649083 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2395458346 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2398205007 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2401014423 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2403557741 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2404257963 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2405742345 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2406779645 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2413377443 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2413495892 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2415248508 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2415772832 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2419039605 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2472530257 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2517151381 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2579206397 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2593007593 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2595509769 @default.
- W4232619078 cites W2605355785 @default.