Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4234662736> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4234662736 endingPage "198" @default.
- W4234662736 startingPage "181" @default.
- W4234662736 abstract "Abstract. Recent attempts to establish the eruptive history of the Deccan Traps large igneous province have used both U−Pb (Schoene et al., 2019) and 40Ar/39Ar (Sprain et al., 2019) geochronology. Both of these studies report dates with high precision and unprecedented coverage for a large igneous province and agree that the main phase of eruptions began near the C30n–C29r magnetic reversal and waned shortly after the C29r–C29n reversal, totaling ∼ 700–800 kyr duration. These datasets can be analyzed in finer detail to determine eruption rates, which are critical for connecting volcanism, associated volatile emissions, and any potential effects on the Earth's climate before and after the Cretaceous–Paleogene boundary (KPB). It is our observation that the community has frequently misinterpreted how the eruption rates derived from these two datasets vary across the KPB. The U−Pb dataset of Schoene et al. (2019) was interpreted by those authors to indicate four major eruptive pulses before and after the KPB. The 40Ar/39Ar dataset did not identify such pulses and has been largely interpreted by the community to indicate an increase in eruption rates coincident with the Chicxulub impact (Renne et al., 2015; Richards et al., 2015). Although the overall agreement in eruption duration is an achievement for geochronology, it is important to clarify the limitations in comparing the two datasets and to highlight paths toward achieving higher-resolution eruption models for the Deccan Traps and for other large igneous provinces. Here, we generate chronostratigraphic models for both datasets using the same statistical techniques and show that the two datasets agree very well. More specifically, we infer that (1) age modeling of the 40Ar/39Ar dataset results in constant eruption rates with relatively large uncertainties through the duration of the Deccan Traps eruptions and provides no support for (or evidence against) the pulses identified by the U−Pb data, (2) the stratigraphic positions of the Chicxulub impact using the 40Ar/39Ar and U−Pb datasets do not agree within their uncertainties, and (3) neither dataset supports the notion of an increase in eruption rate as a result of the Chicxulub impact. We then discuss the importance of systematic uncertainties between the dating methods that challenge direct comparisons between them, and we highlight the geologic uncertainties, such as regional stratigraphic correlations, that need to be tested to ensure the accuracy of eruption models. While the production of precise and accurate geochronologic data is of course essential to studies of Earth history, our analysis underscores that the accuracy of a final result is also critically dependent on how such data are interpreted and presented to the broader community of geoscientists." @default.
- W4234662736 created "2022-05-12" @default.
- W4234662736 creator A5048868100 @default.
- W4234662736 creator A5051866536 @default.
- W4234662736 creator A5071107504 @default.
- W4234662736 creator A5087161655 @default.
- W4234662736 date "2021-04-16" @default.
- W4234662736 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W4234662736 title "An evaluation of Deccan Traps eruption rates using geochronologic data" @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1524586063 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1770113505 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1898112109 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1964057323 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1964523361 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1968325221 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1969089477 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1971216043 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1973615484 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1974975954 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1977204615 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1982572431 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1982846260 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1983044404 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1986662308 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1987192769 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1999019770 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W1999165974 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2002586037 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2009674195 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2018827816 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2024329283 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2026270723 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2029294212 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2038587763 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2039176231 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2047314228 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2061278087 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2063091092 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2066351018 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2069910495 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2072107094 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2074560162 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2077932190 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2079504130 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2082020770 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2083546661 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2083769526 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2098640178 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2100508991 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2110619496 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2114447298 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2120059011 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2122489548 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2126767740 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2127705220 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2133294328 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2136387550 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2148519074 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2150873852 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2154984426 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2155315511 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2158853414 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2160490562 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2166913044 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2187825126 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2198827077 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2344978081 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2489082161 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2515410132 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2553459438 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2560698627 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W256884456 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2577534579 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2587804417 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2602434750 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2619246666 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2737540514 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2756805027 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2767487269 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2769305873 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2773151803 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2786694246 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2802628992 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2888619307 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2891931442 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2895060011 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2915414273 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2915663524 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2917274531 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2917746843 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2922271198 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2951539162 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2952448525 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2969576849 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2977260171 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2980427729 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2982521178 @default.
- W4234662736 cites W2999541819 @default.