Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4240971177> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 74 of
74
with 100 items per page.
- W4240971177 endingPage "208" @default.
- W4240971177 startingPage "207" @default.
- W4240971177 abstract "We thank Drs. Lynes and Griffiths for their comments on our study 1. It was a retrospective analysis of a convenience sample of patients undergoing hip fracture surgery who received pre-operative, goal-focused transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) against a matched cohort who did not. As we discussed, the study design restricts our analysis of the data to ‘hypothesis generation’ or ‘proof of concept’. We firmly believe that a randomised controlled trial is required to accept or reject our hypothesis that pre-operative echocardiography can reduce mortality in such patients. They suggest that the Nottingham Hip Fracture Score (NHFS) is useful as it demonstrated a ‘reasonable predictive value’ for 30-day mortality in nearly 5000 hip fracture surgery patients at a single centre 2, but limitations include validation in a single centre and reliance on pre-operative recording of seven variables. In a follow-up study, 8% of patients were excluded due to missing data such as admission mini-mental state examination and haemoglobin concentration 3. However, ASA status produced very similar predictions to NHFS in the initial study (AUC 0.719 and SE 0.0184 for NHFS and 0.718 and 0.0163 for ASA status) 2. The ASA status predicts incidence and severity of adverse outcomes in multiple centres 4, 5, is the most universally applied risk-scoring system, and was consistently reported in hip fracture surgery patients in our hospital databases. However, the results of our matching produced two cohorts with very similar demographic profiles. Hypovolaemia is a common pre-operative finding in these patients (40–50%) 6, resulting from a combination of blood loss at the fracture site, delay in presentation to hospital and reluctance by medical staff to administer fluids. However, our contention is that clinical assessment of important cardiac disease and haemodynamic state (including hypovolaemia) is frequently incorrect compared with TTE 7. In our study of 64 patients 1, clinical diagnosis of hypovolaemia was missed in 34% (commonly leading to an unplanned fluid bolus), and hypovolaemia was mistaken for cardiac failure in 5% leading to restriction of a planned fluid bolus. Unlike the studies performed by Canty et al., Sinclair et al. and Venn et al. 1, 8, 9, in the study by Parker et al. 10 the amount of fluid given (crystalloid or gelatin colloid) was not guided by ultrasound assessment of intravascular volume, which may be the reason it failed to show an outcome difference. As discussed in our paper 1, TTE-guided fluid therapy is unlikely to be the sole contributor to the associated improved outcome. Our retrospective study method and the potential unreliability of death registry data to ascertain the cause of death precluded us from commenting on the latter. We did not record anaesthetic or surgical staff's experience level, and retrospective data retrieval of this type is unreliable. We cannot determine from our data why echocardiography may reduce mortality. However, echocardiography provides a higher level of diagnostic information to the treating medical team, on which to base clinical decisions. Importantly, it changes anaesthetists' peri-operative management from ‘reactive management’ to ‘proactive management’ 1. For example, undiagnosed aortic stenosis or cardiac failure can lead to a haemodynamic catastrophe, requiring rescue management to restore haemodynamic stability; however, the anaesthetist is likely to manage a patient with known severe aortic stenosis proactively to avoid haemodynamic compromise. Peri-operative cardiac failure is a strong predictor of postoperative mortality 11 and its avoidance by ‘TTE-guided proactive management’ could represent a mechanism of reduction in mortality associated with pre-operative TTE." @default.
- W4240971177 created "2022-05-12" @default.
- W4240971177 creator A5046090412 @default.
- W4240971177 creator A5060387265 @default.
- W4240971177 date "2013-01-09" @default.
- W4240971177 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W4240971177 title "A reply" @default.
- W4240971177 cites W1502333617 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W1969271391 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W1991437594 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2053130694 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2100077316 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2104856491 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2114276156 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2142037869 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2151569522 @default.
- W4240971177 cites W2154625272 @default.
- W4240971177 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/anae.12132" @default.
- W4240971177 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23298348" @default.
- W4240971177 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W4240971177 type Work @default.
- W4240971177 citedByCount "2" @default.
- W4240971177 countsByYear W42409711772013 @default.
- W4240971177 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4240971177 hasAuthorship W4240971177A5046090412 @default.
- W4240971177 hasAuthorship W4240971177A5060387265 @default.
- W4240971177 hasBestOaLocation W42409711771 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C120665830 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C141071460 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C167135981 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C197934379 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C201903717 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C2776541429 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C2778885795 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C3019719930 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C61511704 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConcept C72563966 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C120665830 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C121332964 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C126322002 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C141071460 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C167135981 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C197934379 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C201903717 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C2776541429 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C2778885795 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C3019719930 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C61511704 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C71924100 @default.
- W4240971177 hasConceptScore W4240971177C72563966 @default.
- W4240971177 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W4240971177 hasLocation W42409711771 @default.
- W4240971177 hasLocation W42409711772 @default.
- W4240971177 hasOpenAccess W4240971177 @default.
- W4240971177 hasPrimaryLocation W42409711771 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W1992459022 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2010856554 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2040202189 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2146312256 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2378296015 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2558503409 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W2559287584 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W3172893480 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W4205784260 @default.
- W4240971177 hasRelatedWork W4241836402 @default.
- W4240971177 hasVolume "68" @default.
- W4240971177 isParatext "false" @default.
- W4240971177 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W4240971177 workType "article" @default.