Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4283808878> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4283808878 endingPage "1966" @default.
- W4283808878 startingPage "1948" @default.
- W4283808878 abstract "ABSTRACT In many species that fight over resources, individuals use specialized structures to gain a mechanical advantage over their rivals during contests (i.e. weapons). Although weapons are widespread across animals, how they affect the probability of winning contests is still debated. According to theory, understanding weapon function during contests is essential to: ( i ) understanding its importance in determining the winner, and ( ii ) identifying what weapon traits (e.g. weapon length versus shape versus performance) are most relevant for contest success. However, quantitative evaluations of how weapon function affects the extent to which weapon traits influence contest success are still lacking. Here, we first develop an individual‐based model to evaluate how increasing the influence of the weapon in determining the winner translates to differences between winners and losers. Then, we use a meta‐analysis to identify: ( i ) whether different weapon measures influence contest outcome differently; ( ii ) how animals use their weapons during fights – i.e. weapon function; and ( iii ) if weapon function correlates to how weapons influence contest outcome. Our model showed that, as weapons increased the chance of determining the winner, the mean difference between winners and losers also increased. Therefore, in our meta‐analysis we used the mean trait difference between winners and losers as a proxy for the extent to which weapons influence contest success. The literature search identified 49 suitable studies, containing information for 52 species, totalling 107 effect sizes. Four main patterns emerged. First, most of the literature focuses on linear measures of weapons, while performance measures are concentrated on Crustacea and Squamata; other types of measures were rare. Second, differences between winners and losers in linear measurements were greater than differences in performance measurements when all species were combined (and when we used only a subset). Third, species that bear weapons almost always perform visual/tactile displays before engaging in physical contact. And fourth, while the way individuals display their weapons did not influence the importance of weapon size on contest outcomes, fighting style predicted when differences between winners and losers would be higher. Species that used their weapons to push or lift (even when combined with other functions) showed greater differences between winners and losers when compared to species that used their weapons to impact, pierce, pull or squeeze. Overall, our results show that we have an incomplete understanding of animal weapons built mostly on weapon size and a few select taxa. Thus, we should start focusing on measuring weapons according to how they are used during contests and in a wider diversity of species. One way forward is to conduct studies that integrate weapon morphology to weapon function to ensure we are measuring the most ecologically relevant variables." @default.
- W4283808878 created "2022-07-06" @default.
- W4283808878 creator A5003321925 @default.
- W4283808878 creator A5040300609 @default.
- W4283808878 date "2022-07-04" @default.
- W4283808878 modified "2023-10-09" @default.
- W4283808878 title "The hidden links between animal weapons, fighting style, and their effect on contest success: a meta‐analysis" @default.
- W4283808878 cites W111365456 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1591751230 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1606996339 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1967567937 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1967829443 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1968277768 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1969470645 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1975782471 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1978063875 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1980752060 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1982327380 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1982935621 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1987605827 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W1995362678 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2002307053 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2005362398 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2005559301 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2009374882 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2012521234 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2013362449 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2014540375 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2019256036 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2020851799 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2021667603 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2022297558 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2023171538 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2023957052 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2024735890 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2039228591 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2040400125 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2044025887 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2044577546 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2048998902 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2054208404 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2057280153 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2057636528 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2058289868 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2058358744 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2058618583 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2061745711 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2063709773 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2068723833 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2071171793 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2072198815 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2074943909 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2077059529 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2083070885 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2083419850 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2085683389 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2090145021 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2093342261 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2093394408 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2095407438 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2098808157 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2108492870 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2113768344 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2116789198 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2122265277 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2127042789 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2128003963 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2129011554 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2129331440 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2130867447 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2135568470 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2138036917 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2139168999 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2140316113 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2149241375 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2150210669 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2150285897 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2151409320 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2152648441 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2153279029 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2156665964 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2157823046 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2160036585 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2160503193 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2163330761 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2164862051 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2165546626 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2169356397 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2175400670 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2177436571 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2182506564 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2210040845 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2270017749 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2314671652 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2322715144 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2323470062 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2327583841 @default.
- W4283808878 cites W2420313252 @default.