Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4285677317> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4285677317 endingPage "844" @default.
- W4285677317 startingPage "820" @default.
- W4285677317 abstract "Abstract That policy should be evidence‐based has become a widely accepted dictum, especially in public health, where evidence‐based policy is strongly emphasized. Yet, most public health controversies arise because there is a conflict over values, which facts alone cannot resolve. Moreover, promoting population‐based health interventions requires the art of political actors to arouse public support. In discussing this tension in public health, studies often frame value conflicts as a barrier to rational decision‐making rather than viewing value considerations as an inherent part of democratic policymaking. We argue that by failing to engage value‐conflicts directly, public health professionals actually stymie evidence translation, which requires public and political buy‐in. We suggest a two‐by‐two framework that seeks to make value concerns more explicit in public health policymaking by breaking out policy controversies and alternatives along two dimensions—factual debates and value debates, creating four categories: uncontested alternatives, value debates, fact debates, and contested alternatives . We demonstrate that the policies that are most likely to be contested are those with a strong value conflict and where the evidence‐base is less solid. We also show that the framework is dynamic: fact and value conflicts are neither static nor inevitable. Rather, interested actors use both fact and value to try to push issues from contested to uncontested and vice‐versa. We conclude by demonstrating how the framework can help specify the role of both value and fact debates in public health policymaking through examples from U.S. public health policy controversies, including during the present COVID‐19 crisis." @default.
- W4285677317 created "2022-07-17" @default.
- W4285677317 creator A5014196935 @default.
- W4285677317 creator A5025049015 @default.
- W4285677317 date "2022-07-17" @default.
- W4285677317 modified "2023-10-12" @default.
- W4285677317 title "<scp>Fact‐value</scp> framework for adjudicating public health policy debates" @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1490393546 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1527452312 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W166136788 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1721394419 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W183105666 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1837447861 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1907953089 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1973787774 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1983909602 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1988788575 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W1997713148 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2014525940 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2016701774 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2030708014 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2034285001 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2039132555 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2043839237 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2067893130 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2077891546 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2084786980 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2088763003 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2090342106 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2095038751 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2095631525 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2104122913 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2106952837 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2121079831 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2132998485 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W213449452 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2135283013 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2143362008 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2147109252 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2148572454 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2150469511 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2150514798 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2157812619 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2158654686 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2257269669 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2282602340 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2317195189 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2332796197 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2414691422 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2493564916 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2510383356 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2515598495 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2541419767 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2577177528 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2580102468 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2581765185 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2589219950 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2605986380 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2802739387 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2804280979 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2888023129 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2896110620 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2945030242 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2965536169 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W2975297509 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3016902371 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3037619012 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3090175957 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3124144144 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3124185412 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3131356212 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W3184909194 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4212765250 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4225529700 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4238563299 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4239271802 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4242838114 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W4302767130 @default.
- W4285677317 cites W590989110 @default.
- W4285677317 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12495" @default.
- W4285677317 hasPublicationYear "2022" @default.
- W4285677317 type Work @default.
- W4285677317 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W4285677317 countsByYear W42856773172022 @default.
- W4285677317 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4285677317 hasAuthorship W4285677317A5014196935 @default.
- W4285677317 hasAuthorship W4285677317A5025049015 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C109986646 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C118084267 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C119857082 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C138816342 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C159110408 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C160735492 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W4285677317 hasConcept C190253527 @default.