Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4310074857> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4310074857 abstract "The psychology of reasoning uses norms to categorize responses to reasoning tasks as correct or incorrect in order to interpret the responses and compare them across reasoning tasks. This raises the arbitration problem: any number of norms can be used to evaluate the responses to any reasoning task and there doesn’t seem to be a principled way to arbitrate among them. Elqayam and Evans have argued that this problem is insoluble, so they call for the psychology of reasoning to dispense with norms entirely. Alternatively, Stupple and Ball have argued that norms must be used, but the arbitration problem should be solved by favouring norms that are sensitive to the context, constraints, and goals of human reasoning. In this paper, I argue that the design of reasoning tasks requires the selection of norms that are indifferent to the factors that influence human responses to the tasks—which aren’t knowable during the task design phase, before the task has been given to human subjects. Moreover, I argue that the arbitration problem is easily dissolved: any well-designed task will contain instructions that implicitly or explicitly specify a single determinate norm, which specifies what would count as a solution to the task—independently of the context, constraints, and goals of human reasoning. Finally, I argue that discouraging the use of these a priori task norms may impair the design of novel reasoning tasks." @default.
- W4310074857 created "2022-11-30" @default.
- W4310074857 creator A5017418315 @default.
- W4310074857 date "2022-11-28" @default.
- W4310074857 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W4310074857 title "Arbitrating norms for reasoning tasks" @default.
- W4310074857 cites W1537182967 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W1985985225 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W1997480541 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W1997699194 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2011780588 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2028465691 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2028992008 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2041745738 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2046307716 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2063788410 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2069792529 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2078159446 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2087085457 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2090789917 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2092666517 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2101286810 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2109978697 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2121813011 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2129320919 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2131931917 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2140951507 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2143177887 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2146178167 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2147983650 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2157581667 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2159527690 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2161080627 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2166404875 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2167366201 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2198427466 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2315742094 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2342765135 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2479181559 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2492109479 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2588278186 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2803502566 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2911589237 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2912594580 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2913605716 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W2922085667 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W3124038641 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W3129377105 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W4220923315 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W4231644576 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W4243073981 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W4251648716 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W4292157289 @default.
- W4310074857 cites W621487820 @default.
- W4310074857 doi "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-022-03981-8" @default.
- W4310074857 hasPublicationYear "2022" @default.
- W4310074857 type Work @default.
- W4310074857 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4310074857 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4310074857 hasAuthorship W4310074857A5017418315 @default.
- W4310074857 hasBestOaLocation W43100748572 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C103057564 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C115086926 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C160151201 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C169900460 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C187736073 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C188147891 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C191795146 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C2780451532 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C36964233 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C75553542 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C94124525 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConcept C97364631 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C103057564 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C111472728 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C115086926 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C138885662 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C151730666 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C154945302 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C15744967 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C160151201 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C162324750 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C169760540 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C169900460 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C17744445 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C180747234 @default.
- W4310074857 hasConceptScore W4310074857C187736073 @default.