Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4310546913> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4310546913 endingPage "016146812211409" @default.
- W4310546913 startingPage "016146812211409" @default.
- W4310546913 abstract "Background: The field of mathematics education has made progress toward generating a set of instructional practices that could support improvements in the learning opportunities made available to groups of students who historically have been underserved and marginalized. Studies that contribute to this growing body of work are often conducted in learning environments that are framed as “successful.” As a researcher who is concerned with issues of equity and who acknowledges the importance of closely attending to the quality of the mathematical activity in which students are being asked to engage, my stance on “successful learning environments” pulls from both Gutiérrez’s descriptions of what characterizes classrooms as aiming for equity and the emphasis on the importance of conceptually oriented goals for student learning that is outlined in documents like the Standards. Though as a field we are growing in our knowledge of practices that support these successful learning environments, this knowledge has not yet been reflected in many of the observational tools, rubrics, and protocols used to study these environments. In addition, there is a growing need to develop empirically grounded ways of attending to the extent to which the practices that are being outlined in research literature actually contribute to the “success” of these learning environments. Purpose: The purpose of this article is to explore one way of meeting this growing need by describing the complex work of developing a set of classroom observation rubrics (the Equity and Access Rubrics for Mathematics Instruction, EAR-MI) designed to support efforts in identifying and observing critical features of classrooms characterized as having potential for “success.” In developing the rubrics, I took as my starting place findings from an analysis that compared a set of classrooms that were characterized as demonstrating aspects of successful learning environments and a set of classrooms that were not characterized as successful. This paper not only describes the process of developing the rubrics, but also outlines some of the qualitative differences that distinguished more and less effective examples of the practices the rubrics are designed to capture. Research Design: In designing the rubrics, I engaged in multiple cycles of qualitative analyses of video data collected from a large-scale study. Specifically, I iteratively designed, tested, and revised the developing rubrics while consistently collaborating with, consulting with, and receiving feedback from different experts in the field of education. Conclusions: Although I fully acknowledge and recognize that there are several tensions and limitations of this work, I argue that developing rubrics like the EAR-MI is still worthwhile. One reason that I give for continuing these types of efforts is that it contributes to the work of breaking down forms of practice into components and identifying key aspects of specific practices that are critical for supporting student learning in ways that make potentially productive routines of action visible to and learnable by others, which may ultimately contribute to the development of more successful learning environments. I also argue that rubrics like the EAR-MI have the potential to support researchers in developing stronger evidence of the effectiveness of practices that prior research has identified as critical for marginalized students and in more accurately and concretely identifying and describing learning environments as having potential for “success.”" @default.
- W4310546913 created "2022-12-12" @default.
- W4310546913 creator A5085626289 @default.
- W4310546913 date "2022-12-02" @default.
- W4310546913 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W4310546913 title "Initial Steps in Developing Classroom Observation Rubrics Designed Around Instructional Practices that Support Equity and Access in Classrooms with Potential for “Success”" @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1499074596 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1963516460 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W196560471 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1981821355 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1995503068 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1999074805 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2003810645 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2012748075 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2033582029 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2046790558 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2072342848 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2085259499 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2087109204 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2090326434 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2113038714 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2115565953 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2130512100 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2131601454 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2131855198 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2148247186 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2158677369 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2160053845 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2161513722 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2163358476 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2215375236 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2274086038 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2321807853 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2346143251 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2346999570 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2409015857 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2467537796 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2560140854 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2755553157 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2765162533 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2791271722 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W287480012 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2920908272 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2953435723 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W2979839302 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W4233020791 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W4254799346 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W4283785080 @default.
- W4310546913 cites W1998049024 @default.
- W4310546913 doi "https://doi.org/10.1177/01614681221140963" @default.
- W4310546913 hasPublicationYear "2022" @default.
- W4310546913 type Work @default.
- W4310546913 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4310546913 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4310546913 hasAuthorship W4310546913A5085626289 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C111640148 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C120912362 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C136287216 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C145420912 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C151719136 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C177264268 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C19417346 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C199728807 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C39549134 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConcept C41458344 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C111640148 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C120912362 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C136287216 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C145420912 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C151719136 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C15744967 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C177264268 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C17744445 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C19417346 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C199360897 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C199539241 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C199728807 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C39549134 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C41008148 @default.
- W4310546913 hasConceptScore W4310546913C41458344 @default.
- W4310546913 hasLocation W43105469131 @default.
- W4310546913 hasOpenAccess W4310546913 @default.
- W4310546913 hasPrimaryLocation W43105469131 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W1561376117 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2183361513 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2188943609 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2380389143 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W2994155149 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W3119374904 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W3191733743 @default.
- W4310546913 hasRelatedWork W774971318 @default.