Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4311843544> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4311843544 abstract "Abstract There is a pseudo‐embryology flourishing today, well nourished by popular science, religious ideologies, and the public media. Just as eugenics was a pseudoscience that influenced (and still influences) American popular culture and which was responsible for racist anti‐immigration laws (such as the Immigration Restriction Act of 1924), pseudo‐embryology is also influencing popular culture and legislation. This new pseudoscience promotes the belief that science supports current zygotic and fetal personhood movements as well as anti‐abortion legislation. However, what often passes for science are actually ideological myths, often grounded in and supporting male superiority. Indeed, the first myth of pseudo‐embryology is that fertilization is a masculine act that can be viewed as a classical hero narrative. The second myth is that fertilization is ensoulment, allowing it to displace the feminine act of birth as to when life begins. Here, DNA is seen to play the secular analogue of soul. The third myth is that the fetus in the womb is an independent autonomous entity and that birth merely moves the fetus from the womb to the outside world. This expresses the seed‐in‐the‐soil myth that was also prevalent in ancient cultures. In this manner, masculine stories of fertilization are valorized while feminine narratives of birth are suppressed. So when public narratives discuss what science says about when human life begins, we are not really discussing science. Rather, we are allowing our discussions to fall back into tenacious ancient misogynist myths that have nothing to do with the conclusions of modern developmental biology. Key points There is no consensus among biologists as to when personhood begins. Different biologists have proposed that personhood begins at such events as fertilization, gastrulation, the acquisition of an EEG pattern, and birth. Other scientists claim that the acquisition of personhood is gradual or that the question of personhood is not a biological one. The “science” debated in public discussions is not the set of conclusions based on biological research. Political discussions of reproduction are often based on false culturally‐based stories. Fertilization is falsely perceived as a race of sperm through a passive female, emphasizing male performance rather than interactions and mutual gamete maturation. The genome is falsely depicted as one's soul, promoting the idea that fertilization is ensoulment. Genetic determinism is often assumed, and plasticity ignored. The fetus is falsely depicted as a seed in nutritive soil, autonomous from the mother. The joint nature of maternal and fetal physiologies and anatomies are marginalized. The false narratives combine to form a “pseudo‐embryology” that influences our thoughts and laws." @default.
- W4311843544 created "2023-01-01" @default.
- W4311843544 creator A5077794062 @default.
- W4311843544 date "2022-12-07" @default.
- W4311843544 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W4311843544 title "Pseudo‐embryology and personhood: How embryological pseudoscience helps structure the American abortion debate" @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1494762587 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1500209682 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1507011440 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1858019207 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1964306176 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1983018261 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1990817811 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W1994255822 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2000576401 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2010101647 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2010410878 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2013203343 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2014367144 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2017596003 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2026320186 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2075789547 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2082053667 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2082154560 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2084670685 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2086085426 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2088060893 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2094379452 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2100041989 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2100489386 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2103270251 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2104163600 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2106707996 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2108357420 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2109280818 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2113399583 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2126381692 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2131670325 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2138431753 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2139710410 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2142291836 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2148422863 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2150982004 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2156675957 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2167318746 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2169619812 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2169651905 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2169972560 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2170760271 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2219314901 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2397257516 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2402285925 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2405809219 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2520100072 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2619633146 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2751694218 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2767155938 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2777641772 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2806531878 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2810004005 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2885307934 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2887707547 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2887739248 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2919957599 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2940205897 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2951013808 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2970816531 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2974638051 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W2997201296 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3004188191 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3120831920 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3124221578 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3125933681 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3129591413 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3136766943 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3141181422 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3164583055 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W3206444275 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4206976384 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4235886585 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4236969407 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4239250371 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4240412656 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4240700863 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4243605767 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4253038127 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4294908376 @default.
- W4311843544 cites W4319588628 @default.
- W4311843544 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/ntls.20220041" @default.
- W4311843544 hasPublicationYear "2022" @default.
- W4311843544 type Work @default.
- W4311843544 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4311843544 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4311843544 hasAuthorship W4311843544A5077794062 @default.
- W4311843544 hasBestOaLocation W43118435441 @default.
- W4311843544 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W4311843544 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W4311843544 hasConcept C136815107 @default.
- W4311843544 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W4311843544 hasConcept C140610115 @default.