Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4313372354> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4313372354 endingPage "462" @default.
- W4313372354 startingPage "425" @default.
- W4313372354 abstract "Many cognitive and evolutionary theories of religion argue that supernatural explanations are byproducts of our cognitive adaptations. An influential argument states that our supernatural explanations result from a tendency to generate anthropomorphic explanations, and that this tendency is a byproduct of an error management strategy because agents tend to be associated with especially high fitness costs. We propose instead that anthropomorphic and other supernatural explanations result as features of a broader toolkit of well-designed cognitive adaptations, which are designed for explaining the abstract and causal structure of complex, unobservable, and uncertain phenomena that have substantial impacts on fitness. Specifically, we argue that (1) mental representations about the abstract vs. the supernatural are largely overlapping, if not identical, and (2) when the data-generating processes for scarce and ambiguous observations are complex and opaque, a naive observer can improve a bias-variance trade-off by starting with a simple, underspecified explanation that Western observers readily interpret as “supernatural.” We then argue that (3) in many cases, knowledge specialists across cultures offer pragmatic services that involve apparently supernatural explanations, and their clients are frequently willing to pay them in a market for useful and effective services. We propose that at least some ethnographic descriptions of religion might actually reflect ordinary and adaptive responses to novel problems such as illnesses and natural disasters, where knowledge specialists possess and apply the best available explanations about phenomena that would otherwise be completely mysterious and unpredictable." @default.
- W4313372354 created "2023-01-06" @default.
- W4313372354 creator A5050248607 @default.
- W4313372354 creator A5078545596 @default.
- W4313372354 date "2022-12-01" @default.
- W4313372354 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W4313372354 title "All Models Are Wrong, and Some Are Religious: Supernatural Explanations as Abstract and Useful Falsehoods about Complex Realities" @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1520617657 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1528369519 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1534716451 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1576580351 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1601628689 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1604190406 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W160461043 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1660432851 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1696057967 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1696313190 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1724366325 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W18038509 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1849782225 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1877916171 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1900551443 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1908881143 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1966539968 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1969221628 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1972191699 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1978917939 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1984735186 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W1997162444 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2000630824 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2004108411 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2006189665 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2006307555 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2008915966 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2014019937 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2016030371 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2017294267 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2018259456 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2019443251 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2020155065 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2023095124 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2027702981 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2029246179 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2038128548 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2040908702 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2044203091 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2045895693 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2052860946 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2059100041 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2059799772 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2062959587 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2064143191 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2068883935 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2071048639 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2073307787 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2076207454 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2077198490 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2077877335 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2086094798 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2087883256 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2097686245 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2099782857 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2101003077 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2102827992 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2104256533 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2105361975 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2107577711 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2113647282 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2116598522 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2118448813 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2118476876 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2119858020 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2119898021 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2123081785 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2123713131 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2124434608 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2124720308 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2125270265 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2126392633 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2126976479 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2130929799 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2133659079 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2139619358 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2140386792 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2141538250 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2142793642 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2143164136 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2144862731 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2145860152 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2145919170 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2146570277 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2146722303 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2147806503 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2152367440 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2152417495 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2154594412 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2154933019 @default.
- W4313372354 cites W2157581667 @default.