Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4313609063> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 100 of
100
with 100 items per page.
- W4313609063 abstract "Abstract Scientometers and sociologists of science have spilled much ink on the topic of peer review over the past twenty years given its primordial role in a context marked by the exponential growth of scientific production and the proliferation of predatory journals. Although the topic is addressed under different prisms, few studies have empirically analyzed to what extent it can affect the quality of publications. Here we study (1) the link between the length of reviewers' reports and the citations received by publications, (2) The threshold (expressed in number of words in reviewers' reports) at which the effect on citations becomes statistically significant. To do this, we used data from the Publons database (58,093 peer review reports). We have adjusted this sample to match the WoS database structure. Our regression results show that peer review positively affects the quality of publications. In other words, the more in-depth (longer) the referees' reports are, the greater the publication improvements will be, resulting in an increase in citations received. This result is important from both the point of view of reviewers and that of journal's chiefs-editors. Even if it is not a remunerated activity, it is important that it be more valued at least within the framework of research evaluation exercises, given its positive impact on science. On the thresholds, the results differ between the types of regression used. The threshold is 1250 words (about one page) for Negative Binomial regression, 1400 words for Poisson regression and 2400 words for GLM regression. These results suggest that a report that brings the most value to the publication is a deep report, which naturally requires more time to produce. This is an important result in a context where the deadlines granted to reviewers tend to decrease for some publishers." @default.
- W4313609063 created "2023-01-07" @default.
- W4313609063 creator A5007370813 @default.
- W4313609063 creator A5029050320 @default.
- W4313609063 date "2023-01-06" @default.
- W4313609063 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W4313609063 title "On The Peer Review Reports: Does Size Matter?" @default.
- W4313609063 cites W1968878949 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W1975007423 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2023783748 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2029420412 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2055985373 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2069226445 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2088318994 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2133928412 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2147245877 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2156487032 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2167711310 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2563788691 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2592989848 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2901094534 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2910210452 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W2926567176 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W3008660969 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W3023275883 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W3096170596 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W4210740051 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W4226119337 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W4255691240 @default.
- W4313609063 cites W4376595639 @default.
- W4313609063 doi "https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-2410967/v1" @default.
- W4313609063 hasPublicationYear "2023" @default.
- W4313609063 type Work @default.
- W4313609063 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4313609063 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W4313609063 hasAuthorship W4313609063A5007370813 @default.
- W4313609063 hasAuthorship W4313609063A5029050320 @default.
- W4313609063 hasBestOaLocation W43136090631 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C100906024 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C129848803 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C152877465 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C199335787 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C205649164 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C2524010 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C2776035688 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C2779530757 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C28719098 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C46312422 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C73269764 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConcept C83546350 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C100906024 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C105795698 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C111472728 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C129848803 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C138885662 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C144024400 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C149923435 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C152877465 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C15744967 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C166957645 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C199335787 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C205649164 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C2524010 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C2776035688 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C2779343474 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C2779530757 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C28719098 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C2908647359 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C33923547 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C41008148 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C46312422 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C73269764 @default.
- W4313609063 hasConceptScore W4313609063C83546350 @default.
- W4313609063 hasLocation W43136090631 @default.
- W4313609063 hasOpenAccess W4313609063 @default.
- W4313609063 hasPrimaryLocation W43136090631 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2116166733 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2159796125 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2161850932 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2187337517 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2626535600 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W3135303892 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W3210390693 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W94666533 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2187867992 @default.
- W4313609063 hasRelatedWork W2745491055 @default.
- W4313609063 isParatext "false" @default.
- W4313609063 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W4313609063 workType "article" @default.