Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4317829597> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4317829597 endingPage "31" @default.
- W4317829597 startingPage "1" @default.
- W4317829597 abstract "In this article, we: (1) advance a theory for how courts should respond to highly political disputes about jurisdictional authority, and (2) assess whether courts can achieve this ideal. Our theory draws from normative realism to argue that courts should push conflict back into the political realm whenever possible—facilitating free and fair dialogue by outlining rules and principles to guide negotiations, while also rejecting zero-sum outcomes when enforcing jurisdictional powers and related rights. We favor this approach because it can generate legitimacy for the legal and political systems by recognizing the judiciary’s limited democratic standing in structural disputes. To ground this argument in actual practice, we assess how the Supreme Court of Canada has managed two streams of highly political jurisprudence related to jurisdictional authority—federalism and Aboriginal rights cases. We show that the Court has increasingly relied on this approach of facilitating dialogue in both areas. While we argue that this approach is particularly well suited to federalism cases, our analysis uncovers negative outcomes in Indigenous case law. The Court’s approach often fails to strongly enforce the constitutional rights of Indigenous peoples, demonstrating that its facilitator role does not adequality account for the power imbalances between the state and Indigenous peoples." @default.
- W4317829597 created "2023-01-24" @default.
- W4317829597 creator A5027881316 @default.
- W4317829597 creator A5090897296 @default.
- W4317829597 date "2023-01-24" @default.
- W4317829597 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W4317829597 title "How Should Courts Respond to Political Questions? Exploring the Dialogical Turn in the Supreme Court of Canada’s Federalism and Indigenous Case Law" @default.
- W4317829597 cites W13758951 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1495071821 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1497130442 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1523268308 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1561018600 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1590637385 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1593396212 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1604118981 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W195597089 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1968985905 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W1976031580 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2006647367 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2052476342 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2057113702 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2072706969 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2075608957 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2100052892 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2103492947 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2123513496 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2126328978 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2128659182 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2137662989 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2152768038 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2342334777 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2483444879 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2500003535 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2524042838 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2539682818 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2681524666 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2782677485 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2797111653 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W2890668979 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W3012515956 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W3125191326 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W3161867923 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W3172672511 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W36167030 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4229666626 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4233237171 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4234482627 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4243106458 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4243162678 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4243949015 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4244243890 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4244469453 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4247177159 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4254974485 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4255088189 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4255407569 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W4375932831 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W59334653 @default.
- W4317829597 cites W628559027 @default.
- W4317829597 doi "https://doi.org/10.1017/lsi.2022.89" @default.
- W4317829597 hasPublicationYear "2023" @default.
- W4317829597 type Work @default.
- W4317829597 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4317829597 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4317829597 hasAuthorship W4317829597A5027881316 @default.
- W4317829597 hasAuthorship W4317829597A5090897296 @default.
- W4317829597 hasBestOaLocation W43178295971 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C46295352 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C533735693 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C55958113 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C71043370 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C144024400 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C17744445 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C18903297 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C190253527 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C199539241 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C2778272461 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C46295352 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C533735693 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C55958113 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C71043370 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C86803240 @default.
- W4317829597 hasConceptScore W4317829597C94625758 @default.
- W4317829597 hasLocation W43178295971 @default.
- W4317829597 hasOpenAccess W4317829597 @default.
- W4317829597 hasPrimaryLocation W43178295971 @default.
- W4317829597 hasRelatedWork W1567099302 @default.
- W4317829597 hasRelatedWork W1571041618 @default.
- W4317829597 hasRelatedWork W1604118981 @default.
- W4317829597 hasRelatedWork W2015786629 @default.