Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4361808171> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4361808171 endingPage "396" @default.
- W4361808171 startingPage "389" @default.
- W4361808171 abstract "Objective: To quantify the influence of financial conflict of interest (COI) payments on the reporting of clinical results for robotic surgery. Data Sources and Study Selection: A systematic search (Ovid MEDLINE databases) was conducted (May 2017) to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and observational studies comparing the efficacy of the da Vinci robot on clinical outcomes. Financial COI data for authors (per study) were determined using open payments database. Main Outcomes and Measures: Primary outcomes assessed were receipt of financial COI payments and overall conclusion reported between robotic versus comparative approach. Quality/risk of bias was assessed using Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS)/Cochrane risk of bias tool. Disclosure discrepancies were also analyzed. Data Extraction and Synthesis: Study characteristics, surgical subspecialty, methodological assessment, reporting of disclosure statements, and study findings dual abstracted. The association of the amount of financial support received as a predictor of reporting positive findings associated robotic surgery was assessed at various cut-offs of dollar amount received by receiver operating curve (ROC). Results: Thirty-three studies were included, 9 RCTs and 24 observational studies. There was a median, 111 patients (range 10 to 6420) across studies. A little more than half (17/33) had a conclusion statement reporting positive results in support of robotic surgery, with 48% (16/33) reporting results not in favor [equivocal: 12/33 (36%), negative: 4/33 (12%)]. Nearly all (91%) studies had authors who received financial COI payments, with a median of $3364.46 per study (range $9 to $1,775,378.03). ROC curve demonstrated that studies receiving greater than $9557.31 (cutpoint) were more likely to report positive robotic surgery results (sensitivity: 0.65, specificity: 0.81, area under the curve: 0.73). Studies with financial COI payment greater than this amount were more likely to report beneficial outcomes with robotic surgery [(78.57% vs 31.58%, P = 0.013) with an odds ratio of 2.07 (confidence interval: 0.47–3.67; P = 0.011)]. Overall, studies were high quality/low risk of bias [median NOS: 8 (range 5 to 9)]; Cochrane risk: “low risk” (9/9, 100%)]. Conclusion and Relevance: Financial COI sponsorship appears to be associated with a higher likelihood of studies reporting a benefit of robotic surgery. Our findings suggest a dollar amount where financial payments influence reported clinical results, a concept that challenges the current guidelines, which do not account for the amount of COI funding received." @default.
- W4361808171 created "2023-04-05" @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5007161634 @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5012494640 @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5026340905 @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5047093371 @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5056564228 @default.
- W4361808171 creator A5069321101 @default.
- W4361808171 date "2019-03-01" @default.
- W4361808171 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W4361808171 title "The Impact of Corporate Payments on Robotic Surgery Research" @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1232329674 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1963579789 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1968730850 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1974964026 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1980599286 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1983123996 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1997039476 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W1998505973 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2011506948 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2013639419 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2017798008 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2025631053 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2027629571 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2027636074 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2039195937 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2042869433 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2045559857 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2048600270 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2052488704 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2053664176 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2055192766 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2059433035 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2065848562 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2073625861 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2074645659 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2075720069 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2076941259 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2080218276 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2080417881 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2091905553 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2098827191 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2099090757 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2099606826 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2100433691 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2111145039 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2125833000 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2137550346 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2142947341 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2143326731 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2143731060 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2152340675 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2154422166 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2156059179 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2156609154 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2157822962 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2174212531 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2179153568 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2312629287 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2335635604 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2357440031 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2414368808 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2416033297 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2435668118 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2508801071 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2528285088 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2534812076 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2548052643 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2551459463 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2582737496 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2585256549 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2589501886 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2590025457 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2592910401 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2601745884 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2616669820 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2736195052 @default.
- W4361808171 cites W2749671667 @default.
- W4361808171 doi "https://doi.org/10.1097/sla.0000000000003000" @default.
- W4361808171 hasPublicationYear "2019" @default.
- W4361808171 type Work @default.
- W4361808171 citedByCount "23" @default.
- W4361808171 countsByYear W43618081712019 @default.
- W4361808171 countsByYear W43618081712020 @default.
- W4361808171 countsByYear W43618081712021 @default.
- W4361808171 countsByYear W43618081712022 @default.
- W4361808171 countsByYear W43618081712023 @default.
- W4361808171 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5007161634 @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5012494640 @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5026340905 @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5047093371 @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5056564228 @default.
- W4361808171 hasAuthorship W4361808171A5069321101 @default.
- W4361808171 hasConcept C10138342 @default.
- W4361808171 hasConcept C121955636 @default.
- W4361808171 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W4361808171 hasConcept C141071460 @default.