Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4376617913> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4376617913 abstract "Abstract Background To evaluate the number of citations for Cochrane Methodology Reviews after they have been updated or co-published in another journal. Methods We identified all Cochrane Methodology Reviews published in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews ( CDSR ) before 2018 and searched for any versions co-published in another journal in the Web of Science Core Collection database up to 16 August 2022. The included reviews were in two cohorts: those that had been published and updated in CDSR and those that had been published in CDSR and co-published in another journal. The primary outcomes were the number of citations to the updated and the original Cochrane Reviews in the five years after the updated review had been published and the number of citations to co-published and non-co-published Cochrane Reviews in the first five years after publication of the co-published version. The secondary outcome was the ratio of an adjusted impact factor (IF) (excluding the data for the co-published Cochrane Review) and the actual IF of the co-publishing journal. Results Eight updated and six original Cochrane reviews were identified for the first cohort of reviews, and four co-published Cochrane reviews were included in the second cohort. The original versions of Cochrane Methodology Reviews continued to be cited after the update was published but the median for the total number of citations was non-significantly higher for the updated Cochrane reviews than for their original version after the publication of the updated review [161 (Interquartile range (IQR) 85, 198) versus 113 (IQR 15, 433), p>0.05]. The difference was mainly due to citations in the fourth and fifth year after publication of the update [21 (IQR 10, 49) versus 13 (IQR 4, 53), 30 (IQR 10, 34) versus 10 (IQR 5, 42), all p>0.05], with the median number of citations being lower for the update than for the original version in the first year [2 (IQR 0, 4) versus 20 (IQR 8, 51)] and in the second year [14 (IQR 7, 21) versus 24 (IQR 6, 50)] and similar in the third year [18 (IQR 9, 35) versus 19 (IQR 6, 63)]. All the differences were not statistically significant. The median number of total citations [362 (IQR 179, 840) versus 145 (IQR 75, 445)] and the median number of citations to the Cochrane review in the first five years after co-publication combined and in each of those years was higher in the co-published group (including both the original review and the co-published version) than in the non-co-published group [first year: 6 (IQR 1, 23) versus 1 (IQR 0, 3); second year: 29 (IQR 16, 63) versus 13 (IQR 5, 17); third year: 36 (IQR 22, 90) versus 19 (IQR 9, 34); fourth year: 37 (IQR 23, 82) versus 22 (IQR 10, 34); fifth year: 59 (IQR 30, 99) versus 15 (IQR 8, 32); sum of years 1-5: 177 (IQR 99, 338) versus 75 (IQR 37, 126)]. The analysis of the adjusted IF showed that, if they had not co-published the Cochrane review, one of the three journals that co-published a Cochrane Methodology Review would have had a lower IF in the first year after the co-publication and two would have had a lower IF in the second year after the co-publication. Conclusions Earlier versions of Cochrane Methodology Reviews continue to be cited after an update is published, which raises doubts about whether those citing these reviews are using the most recent evidence or are aware of the update. Co-publication is associated with a higher overall citation frequency for Cochrane Methodology Reviews and may increase the IF of the journal in which it is co-published, which facilitates broader application of Cochrane evidence on the methodology of research and promotes its dissemination." @default.
- W4376617913 created "2023-05-17" @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5023583209 @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5035891540 @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5042202542 @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5076621575 @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5086150709 @default.
- W4376617913 creator A5086859935 @default.
- W4376617913 date "2023-05-15" @default.
- W4376617913 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W4376617913 title "Citation of updated and co-published Cochrane Methodology Reviews" @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1566155680 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1592653824 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1714980748 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1785898356 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1903682179 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1919332000 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1931845227 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1939936598 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1942053905 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W1989605230 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2010810301 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2033069678 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2035341793 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2039278910 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2045566419 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2077611838 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2095589089 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2110140939 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2119858271 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2129530569 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2150229987 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2161853770 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2163978340 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2489347314 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2788630491 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2808548841 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2888260605 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2902790381 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2947139456 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2950177542 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W2969467855 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W3000533096 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W3101830111 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W3107446044 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W3110617326 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W3167054959 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4200287413 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4211062734 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4236290062 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4245428103 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4247545969 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4252017059 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4281650877 @default.
- W4376617913 cites W4281751324 @default.
- W4376617913 doi "https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-2792008/v1" @default.
- W4376617913 hasPublicationYear "2023" @default.
- W4376617913 type Work @default.
- W4376617913 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4376617913 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5023583209 @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5035891540 @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5042202542 @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5076621575 @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5086150709 @default.
- W4376617913 hasAuthorship W4376617913A5086859935 @default.
- W4376617913 hasBestOaLocation W43766179131 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C161191863 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C189708586 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C2776478404 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C2778805511 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C2779473830 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C3020774429 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConcept C95190672 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C126322002 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C161191863 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C185592680 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C189708586 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C2776478404 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C2778805511 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C2779473830 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C3020774429 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C41008148 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C55493867 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C71924100 @default.
- W4376617913 hasConceptScore W4376617913C95190672 @default.
- W4376617913 hasLocation W43766179131 @default.
- W4376617913 hasOpenAccess W4376617913 @default.
- W4376617913 hasPrimaryLocation W43766179131 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W2990575572 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W3027459656 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W3082854370 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W3117110396 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W3134414398 @default.
- W4376617913 hasRelatedWork W4207082034 @default.