Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4376983040> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4376983040 abstract "Rubric-based admissions are claimed to help make the graduate admissions process more equitable, possibly helping to address the historical and ongoing inequities in the U.S. physics graduate school admissions process that have often excluded applicants from minoritized races, ethnicities, genders, and backgrounds. Yet, no studies have examined whether rubric-based admissions methods represent a fundamental change of the admissions process or simply represent a new tool that achieves the same outcome. To address that, we developed supervised machine learning models of graduate admissions data collected from our department over a seven-year period. During the first four years, our department used a traditional admissions process and switched to a rubric-based process for the following three years, allowing us to compare which parts of the applications were used to drive admissions decisions. We find that faculty focused on applicants' physics GRE scores and grade point averages when making admissions decisions before the implementation of the rubric. While we were able to develop a sufficiently good model whose results we could trust for the data before the implementation of the rubric, we were unable to do so for the data collected after the implementation of the rubric, despite multiple modifications to the algorithms and data such as implementing Tomek Links. Our inability to model the second data set despite being able to model the first combined with model comparison analyses suggests that rubric-based admissions does change the underlying process. These results suggest that rubric-based holistic review is a method that could make the graduate admissions process in physics more equitable." @default.
- W4376983040 created "2023-05-18" @default.
- W4376983040 creator A5004433256 @default.
- W4376983040 creator A5013005387 @default.
- W4376983040 creator A5051308786 @default.
- W4376983040 creator A5089908381 @default.
- W4376983040 date "2023-05-15" @default.
- W4376983040 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W4376983040 title "Rubric-based holistic review represents a change from traditional graduate admissions approaches in physics" @default.
- W4376983040 cites W1520812622 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W1591261915 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W1875061881 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W1988195734 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W1993220166 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2005595012 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2017665047 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2037264503 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2098752269 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2108096958 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2115098571 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2118502261 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2120153268 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2140534668 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2143481518 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2150706391 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2167277498 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2511002675 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2776515235 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2787894218 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2794769810 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2888688605 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2891381594 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2897267723 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2909854053 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2911964244 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2912761739 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2954236196 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2972084110 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2975489583 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W2993743691 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3005040148 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3095150750 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3095525721 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3104353950 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3115319453 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3122320482 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3122577968 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3129516645 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3132770312 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3186567754 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3198552520 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3205388893 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3209434414 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3215209784 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3215763431 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W3216410477 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W4226278326 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W4246259708 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W4255375128 @default.
- W4376983040 cites W4285653646 @default.
- W4376983040 doi "https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevphyseducres.19.010134" @default.
- W4376983040 hasPublicationYear "2023" @default.
- W4376983040 type Work @default.
- W4376983040 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W4376983040 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W4376983040 hasAuthorship W4376983040A5004433256 @default.
- W4376983040 hasAuthorship W4376983040A5013005387 @default.
- W4376983040 hasAuthorship W4376983040A5051308786 @default.
- W4376983040 hasAuthorship W4376983040A5089908381 @default.
- W4376983040 hasBestOaLocation W43769830401 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C111640148 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C145420912 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C177264268 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C2522767166 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C509550671 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConcept C98045186 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C111640148 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C111919701 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C145420912 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C15744967 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C177264268 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C199360897 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C2522767166 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C41008148 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C509550671 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C71924100 @default.
- W4376983040 hasConceptScore W4376983040C98045186 @default.
- W4376983040 hasFunder F4320333900 @default.
- W4376983040 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W4376983040 hasLocation W43769830401 @default.
- W4376983040 hasLocation W43769830402 @default.
- W4376983040 hasLocation W43769830403 @default.
- W4376983040 hasOpenAccess W4376983040 @default.
- W4376983040 hasPrimaryLocation W43769830401 @default.
- W4376983040 hasRelatedWork W136615508 @default.