Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4385220450> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4385220450 endingPage "102210" @default.
- W4385220450 startingPage "102210" @default.
- W4385220450 abstract "Although peer review is a widely-used pedagogical technique, its value depends upon the quality of the reviews that students produce, and much research remains to be done to systematically study the nature, causes, and consequences of variation in peer review quality. We propose a new framework that conceptualizes five larger dimensions of peer review quality and then present a study that investigated three specific peer review quality constructs in a large dataset and further explored how these constructs change through different types of self-regulation peer reviewing experiences. Peer review data across multiple assignments were analyzed from 2,092 undergraduate students enrolled in one of three offerings of a biology course at a large public research university in the United States. Peer review quality was measured in terms of comment amount, comment accuracy, and rating accuracy; the measures of reviewing experience focused upon self-regulated learning factors such as practice, feedback, others’ modeling, and relative performance. Meta-correlation (for testing reliability, separability, and stability) and meta-regression (as a time-series analysis for testing the relationship of changes across assignments in reviewing quality with experiences as reviewer and reviewee) are used to establish the robustness of effects and meaningful variation of effects across course offerings and assignments. Results showed that there were three meaningful review quality constructs (i.e., were measured reliably, separable, and semi-stable over time). Further, all three showed changes in response to previous reviewer and reviewee experiences, but only feedback helpfulness, in particular, showed effects of all four examined types of self-regluation experiences (practice, feedback, others’ modeling, and relative performance). The findings suggest that instructors can improve review quality by providing comment prompt scaffolds that lead to longer comments as well as by matching authors with similarly performing reviewers." @default.
- W4385220450 created "2023-07-25" @default.
- W4385220450 creator A5012249136 @default.
- W4385220450 creator A5016157521 @default.
- W4385220450 date "2023-07-01" @default.
- W4385220450 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W4385220450 title "Self-regulation of peer feedback quality aspects through different dimensions of experience within prior peer feedback assignments" @default.
- W4385220450 cites W1507514160 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W1520074575 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W1976450472 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W1983799571 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W1989213880 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2002992299 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2017343061 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2021825464 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2024583961 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2031192422 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2031852740 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2035845321 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2061439446 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2062251337 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2067724039 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2075371609 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2089801766 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2091931022 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2097038473 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2098992709 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2101783467 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2110587911 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2110661236 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2111201581 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2115389369 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2116917334 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2129476861 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2140661853 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2141413057 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2142064267 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2146267631 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2148189517 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2157381667 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2165789759 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2169570446 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2173034410 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2228459624 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2292054779 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2490504474 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2535628851 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2573443938 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2596072174 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2611357751 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2613691046 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2750398140 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2753980708 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2758716852 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2772591722 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2772931195 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2794311125 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2795596428 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2801431714 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2892447306 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2903819721 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2907199351 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2936890192 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2948588714 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2965283781 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2966108802 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2988610529 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2990390600 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2992007770 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W2996399622 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W299930192 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3005296577 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3044104699 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3044862824 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3046266703 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3086595731 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3094237923 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3112885515 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3120778642 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3124289147 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3160045617 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3176997313 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3177058820 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3181407203 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3197987665 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3198166203 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3200414807 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3202327299 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3204150401 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3207037642 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W3212954735 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4210896153 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4214557348 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4220863826 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4233972215 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4280598345 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4281719164 @default.
- W4385220450 cites W4282983277 @default.