Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W4386570619> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W4386570619 endingPage "104920" @default.
- W4386570619 startingPage "104920" @default.
- W4386570619 abstract "Argumentation involves collaboration and regulation of learning. In recent years, regulation of learning, which involves self-, co-, and socially shared regulations, has attracted much attention across a range of domains. To date, studies on these forms of regulation, especially on cognitive regulation, have explored the temporal and sequential patterns of regulatory processes using various sample sizes, especially in collaborative learning, whereas few studies were found on how different argumentation scaffolds affect the structure of these three types of regulation. With the maturity of cloud computing and 5G technology, many kinds of collaborative whiteboards can be adopted to support students' argumentation. In this study, Toulmin's Argument Pattern (TAP) and Nussbaum's Argument Vee Diagram (AVD) scaffolds were integrated into an online whiteboard to assist with collaborative argumentation. A total of 193 pre-service teachers of five intact classes were recruited and evenly assigned to the control cohort, the TAP cohort and the AVD cohort. This study conducted a quasi-experiment for 6 weeks, collecting pretests on prior instructional design knowledge & prior argumentation skills and individual metacognition as covariates, screen recording of online whiteboard-based argumentation activities, and group argumentative reports. Using MANCOVA and epistemic network analysis (ENA), this study drew the following conclusions: (1) Compared to the conventional discussion, TAP and AVD scaffolds respectively activated prominently more self-regulation and co-regulation. However, in socially shared regulation, there was no significant difference between the two scaffolds and the conventional discussion; (2) The TAP and AVD scaffolds significantly enhanced students' written argument skills compared to the conventional discussion, but no significant difference existed in the TAP and AVD scaffolds for improving students' written argument skills since the AVD scaffold evoked a great deal of ineffective co-regulation; (3) In the claim phase, the TAP scaffold activated a stronger connection between co-regulation and socially shared regulation than the other two scaffolds, while the AVD scaffold had a connection between self-regulation and socially shared regulation that was stronger than the conventional discussion and as strong as the TAP scaffold. In the justification phase, the AVD scaffold showed a far stronger connection between self-regulation and co-regulation, while the TAP scaffold illustrated a stronger connection between co-regulation and socially shared regulation. In the rebuttal phase, all three scaffolds showed the strongest connection between self-regulation and co-regulation. This study has implications for effectively using online whiteboards to support productive argumentation, in turn boosting argumentation skills along with regulation characteristics of productive argumentation." @default.
- W4386570619 created "2023-09-10" @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5004291741 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5049547394 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5071346478 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5072567079 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5082024598 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5084969567 @default.
- W4386570619 creator A5092832137 @default.
- W4386570619 date "2023-12-01" @default.
- W4386570619 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W4386570619 title "Effects of online whiteboard-based collaborative argumentation scaffolds on group-level cognitive regulations, written argument skills and regulation patterns" @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1521753475 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1774658512 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1864420497 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1893385445 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1965275228 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1965610167 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1965646521 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1966663571 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1968146591 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1974039775 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1974778300 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1985592418 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1995671839 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W1998383371 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2004408987 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2004713943 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2012879363 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2030211381 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2033364936 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2036700197 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2039446461 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2041650465 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2044257079 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2045572793 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2052033074 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2056205967 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2082952825 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2089228108 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2094364910 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2100817584 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2103258272 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2106451027 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2114509888 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2116727943 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2123189502 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2137654724 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2146455353 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2153727825 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2157799834 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2164185374 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2168353148 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2176924016 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2279353084 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2443246270 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2501064304 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2547096835 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2556115049 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2563946746 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2582491534 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2585780990 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2742538179 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2759596001 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2762580271 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2779913130 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2781032877 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2806641522 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2884699152 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2886116419 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2900767308 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2910782037 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2921496098 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2922963020 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2945967129 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W2979505522 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3008251415 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3023129332 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3023421177 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3033571165 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3040045935 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3044664329 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3091929488 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3094165474 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3102936684 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3110973062 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3112562081 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3126249787 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3133595252 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3135575916 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3165882626 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3172492306 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3174839757 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3180685280 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W3208828298 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W347186812 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W4200315994 @default.
- W4386570619 cites W4214808815 @default.