Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W53825314> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W53825314 abstract "of a dissertation at the University of Miami. Dissertation supervised by Professor Carlos A. Flores. No. of pages in text. (116) There has been a recent increase on research focusing on partial identification of average treatment effects in the program evaluation literature. In contrast with traditional point identification, partial identification approaches derive bounds on parameters of interest based on relatively weak assumptions. Thus, they deliver more credible results in empirical applications. This dissertation extends Instrumental Variable (IV) methods in the program evaluation literature by partially identifying treatment effects of interest when evaluating a program or intervention. An influential approach for studying causality within the IV framework was developed by Imbens and Angrist (1994) and Angrist, Imbens and Rubin (1996). They show that, when allowing for heterogeneous effects, IV estimators point identify the local average treatment effect (LATE) for compliers, whose treatment status is affected by the instrument. This dissertation advances the current IV literature in two important ways. First, inspired by the common criticism that LATE lacks external validity, this dissertation derives sharp nonparametric bounds for population average treatment effects (ATE) within the LATE framework. Second, the dissertation extends the LATE framework to bound treatment effects in the presence of both sample selection and noncompliance. Even when employing randomized experiments to evaluate programs -as is now common in economics and other social science fields -assessing the impact of the treatment on outcomes of interest is often made difficult by those two critical identification problems. The sample selection issue arises when outcomes of interest are only observed for a selected group. The noncompliance problem appears because some treatment group individuals do not receive the treatment while some control individuals do. The dissertation addresses both of these identification problems simultaneously and derives nonparametric bounds for average treatment effects within a principal stratification framework. More generally, these bounds can be employed in settings where two identification problems are present and there is a valid instrument to address one of them. The bounds derived in this dissertation are based on two sets of relatively weak assumptions: monotonicity assumptions on potential outcomes within specified subpopulations, and mean dominance assumptions across subpopulations. The dissertation employs the derived bounds to evaluate the effectiveness of the Job Corps (JC) program, which is the largest federally-funded job training program for disadvantaged youth in the United States, with the focus on labor market outcomes and welfare dependence. The dissertation uses data from an experimental evaluation of JC. Individuals were randomly assigned to a treatment group (whose members were allowed to enroll in JC) or to a control group (whose members were denied access to JC for three years). However, there was noncompliance: some individuals who were assigned to participate in JC did not enroll, while some individuals assigned to the control group did. The dissertation addresses this noncompliance issue using random assignment as an IV for enrollment into JC. Concentrating on the population ATE, JC enrollment increases weekly earnings by at least $24.61 and employment by at least 4.3 percentage points four years after randomization, and decreases yearly dependence on public welfare benefits by at least $84.29. These bounds are significantly narrower than the ones derived in the current IV literature. The dissertation also evaluates the effect of JC on wages, which are observed only for those who are employed. Hence, the sample selection issue has to be addressed when evaluating this effect. In the presence of sample selection and noncompliance, the average treatment effect of JC enrollment on wages for the alwaysemployed compliers, who would comply with their assigned treatment and who would be always employed regardless of their assignment statuses, is bounded between 5.7 percent and 13.9 percent four years after random assignment. The results suggest greater positive average effects of JC on wages than those found in the literature evaluating JC without adjusting for noncompliance. The dissertation closes by pointing out that a similar analytic strategy to the one used in this dissertation can be used to address other problems, for example, to bound the ATE when the instrument does not satisfy the exclusion restriction, and to derive bounds on the part of the effect of a treatment on an outcome that works through a given mechanism (i.e., direct or net effects) in the presence of one identification issue (e.g., noncompliance)." @default.
- W53825314 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W53825314 creator A5080351006 @default.
- W53825314 date "2013-07-11" @default.
- W53825314 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W53825314 title "Partial identification of average treatment effects in program evaluation: Theory and applications" @default.
- W53825314 cites W1516659296 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1519840136 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1547800545 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1554651550 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1564672682 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1592029503 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1605552950 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1969342419 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1980801036 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2001820152 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2007283076 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2034058229 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2044366145 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2048261152 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2048819216 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2058330051 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2064556123 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2081566815 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2100358124 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2103130810 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2104035465 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2105372138 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2112903727 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2114245126 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2119515738 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2123510268 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2128895858 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2130124089 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2138290169 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2138365793 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2139122730 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2144512268 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2152975636 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2159026487 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2167199524 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2169124073 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2260887458 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2314734263 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2890543633 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3025771340 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3121385028 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3121556564 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3122892498 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3123675120 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3124428087 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3125855424 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3125974135 @default.
- W53825314 cites W3159559923 @default.
- W53825314 cites W1999637731 @default.
- W53825314 cites W2555065872 @default.
- W53825314 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W53825314 type Work @default.
- W53825314 sameAs 53825314 @default.
- W53825314 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W53825314 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W53825314 hasAuthorship W53825314A5080351006 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C116834253 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C149782125 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C155108698 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C162118730 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C162144332 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C185429906 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C40423286 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C59822182 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C64357122 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C89337504 @default.
- W53825314 hasConcept C99454951 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C105795698 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C116834253 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C121332964 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C149782125 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C155108698 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C162118730 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C162144332 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C162324750 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C185429906 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C2908647359 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C33923547 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C40423286 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C41008148 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C59822182 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C62520636 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C64357122 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C71924100 @default.
- W53825314 hasConceptScore W53825314C86803240 @default.