Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W607733962> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 75 of
75
with 100 items per page.
- W607733962 endingPage "298" @default.
- W607733962 startingPage "287" @default.
- W607733962 abstract "My question is: does phenomenal consciousness have a critical role in explaining the way conscious perceptions achieve objective import? I approach it through developing a dilemma I label ‘Burge’s Challenge’, which is implicit in his approach to perceptual objectivity. It says, crudely: either endorse the general structure of his account of how objective perceptual import is achieved (an account I label ‘Caused Representation’), and give up on a role for consciousness. Or, relinquish Caused Representation, and possibly defend a role for consciousness. Someone I call Burge* holds we should embrace the first horn of the dilemma. A second response, roughly the relationalist approach, opts for the second horn. The third option, implicit in many current approaches to perceptual consciousness, is to reject the dilemma. The paper argues for a version of the second response. The key argument turns on the development of a sceptical challenge to justify the assumption that we perceive particular intrinsic property instantiations, rather than their structural equivalents. The suggestion will be that only the relationalist approach can meet it in the way we think it is met. If this is right, there is a prima facie case for taking relationalist responses to the dilemma seriously. I end with two objections to this response, which might be made by the real Burge in defence of opting for the first horn of the dilemma, and by phenomenal intentionalists in defence of rejecting the dilemma. I use discussion of these to highlight one of the main issues that should be pursued in order to make good the claim that we should embrace the horn of the dilemma that Burge* rejects." @default.
- W607733962 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W607733962 creator A5057622145 @default.
- W607733962 date "2015-06-14" @default.
- W607733962 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W607733962 title "Perceptual Objectivity and Consciousness: A Relational Response to Burge’s Challenge" @default.
- W607733962 cites W12761828 @default.
- W607733962 cites W1913327626 @default.
- W607733962 cites W1982714651 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2012903676 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2014592583 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2053263976 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2089799012 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2109701144 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2113974159 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2162317853 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2164446969 @default.
- W607733962 cites W21782270 @default.
- W607733962 cites W2631768963 @default.
- W607733962 cites W369623551 @default.
- W607733962 cites W4212947750 @default.
- W607733962 cites W4234970796 @default.
- W607733962 cites W4239321408 @default.
- W607733962 cites W4255398554 @default.
- W607733962 cites W4300660636 @default.
- W607733962 doi "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-015-9325-4" @default.
- W607733962 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W607733962 type Work @default.
- W607733962 sameAs 607733962 @default.
- W607733962 citedByCount "5" @default.
- W607733962 countsByYear W6077339622017 @default.
- W607733962 countsByYear W6077339622019 @default.
- W607733962 countsByYear W6077339622020 @default.
- W607733962 countsByYear W6077339622022 @default.
- W607733962 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W607733962 hasAuthorship W607733962A5057622145 @default.
- W607733962 hasBestOaLocation W6077339622 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C159717818 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C186720457 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C2482559 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C26760741 @default.
- W607733962 hasConcept C2778496695 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C111472728 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C138885662 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C15744967 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C159717818 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C186720457 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C2482559 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C26760741 @default.
- W607733962 hasConceptScore W607733962C2778496695 @default.
- W607733962 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W607733962 hasLocation W6077339621 @default.
- W607733962 hasLocation W6077339622 @default.
- W607733962 hasOpenAccess W607733962 @default.
- W607733962 hasPrimaryLocation W6077339621 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2044410703 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2128548725 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2155284065 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2514608820 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2692980276 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W2972014066 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W341070745 @default.
- W607733962 hasRelatedWork W607733962 @default.
- W607733962 hasVolume "36" @default.
- W607733962 isParatext "false" @default.
- W607733962 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W607733962 magId "607733962" @default.
- W607733962 workType "article" @default.