Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W60921352> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 68 of
68
with 100 items per page.
- W60921352 abstract "In this article, I examine the use of gay panic defense strategies in the criminal courtroom. I argue that such strategies are problematic because they reinforce and promote negative stereotypes about gay men as sexual deviants and sexual predators. Gay panic defense strategies are also troubling because they seek to capitalize on unconscious bias in favor of heterosexuality which is prevalent in today's heterocentric society. Most critics of the gay panic defense have proposed that judges or legislatures should bar gay panic arguments from the criminal courtroom. I take a contrary position and argue that banning gay panic arguments from the criminal courtroom is a bad idea. When gay panic arguments are forced to take a covert turn - when they are not explicit or out in the open - they may actually be more effective. Recent social science research on race and implicit bias suggests that making race salient can diminish the otherwise automatic effect of stereotypes on perception and belief. Conversely, pretending that race is irrelevant and not making it salient allows unconscious racism to operate without any constraints. The same is likely true of other types of bias, including sexual orientation bias. Rather than precluding defendants from making gay panic arguments, I argue that the criminal courtroom is the place where such arguments can and should be aired and battled. The article proceeds in three parts. In Part I, I review the historical origins of the concept of gay panic. In Part II, I examine the doctrinal underpinnings of gay panic defense strategies and theorize about why gay panic arguments are successful. Defendants have linked claims of gay panic to criminal law defenses based on mental deficiency, such as temporary insanity or diminished capacity. More recently, gay panic has been used to bolster claims of provocation and self-defense. I also examine the trans-panic defense, a fairly recent modification of the gay panic defense under which a male murder defendant charged with murdering a transgender individual claims that he panicked upon learning that his sexual partner was biologically male, not female. In Part III, I strike a different path from that chosen by other critics of the gay panic defense. Other critics have proposed essentially the same remedy: barring defendants from arguing gay panic. In contrast, I argue that judges should as a general rule allow such arguments as long as some evidence supports the traditional criminal law defense that the defendant is asserting through the gay panic lens. This is the same standard governing when a trial court must allow a proffered defense used in numerous jurisdictions. To bolster this possibly unpopular position, I start with a micro-argument: attempts to ban gay panic from the criminal courtroom won't work because gay panic arguments can be made sub rosa. I then turn to what might be called macro arguments to support my theory that banning gay panic defense strategies from the criminal courtroom is a bad idea. Three broader frameworks support my position: (1) First Amendment theory; (2) recent social science research on implicit bias; and (3) institutional competency arguments." @default.
- W60921352 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W60921352 creator A5016750719 @default.
- W60921352 date "2008-06-07" @default.
- W60921352 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W60921352 title "The Gay Panic Defense" @default.
- W60921352 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
- W60921352 type Work @default.
- W60921352 sameAs 60921352 @default.
- W60921352 citedByCount "6" @default.
- W60921352 countsByYear W609213522013 @default.
- W60921352 countsByYear W609213522014 @default.
- W60921352 countsByYear W609213522015 @default.
- W60921352 countsByYear W609213522017 @default.
- W60921352 countsByYear W609213522021 @default.
- W60921352 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W60921352 hasAuthorship W60921352A5016750719 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C11171543 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C115786838 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C118552586 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C151884938 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C2779338814 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C2780712732 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C558461103 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C73484699 @default.
- W60921352 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C11171543 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C115786838 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C118552586 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C138885662 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C151884938 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C15744967 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C2779338814 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C2780712732 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C41895202 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C558461103 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C73484699 @default.
- W60921352 hasConceptScore W60921352C77805123 @default.
- W60921352 hasLocation W609213521 @default.
- W60921352 hasOpenAccess W60921352 @default.
- W60921352 hasPrimaryLocation W609213521 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W118627909 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1481907306 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1570266217 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1768602498 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1772284678 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1857064883 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W1857406179 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2090339032 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2202474235 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2208230548 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2208344410 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2252815909 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2267421889 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2485533537 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2798152316 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2884567952 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W2995833495 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W3011635261 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W3126062395 @default.
- W60921352 hasRelatedWork W40033472 @default.
- W60921352 isParatext "false" @default.
- W60921352 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W60921352 magId "60921352" @default.
- W60921352 workType "article" @default.