Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W632328669> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W632328669 endingPage "165" @default.
- W632328669 startingPage "129" @default.
- W632328669 abstract "The main object of this paper is to present, through a close examination of his relationship with Georg von Lukacs1 in Heidelberg from 1912-1914, Max Weber's understanding of Marxism. The argument that follows is, in preliminary fashion, that the younger Lukacs, whose own work during this period took a turn in the direction of Marxism, directly influenced Weber's eventual stance toward Marxism as articulated in his swansong address, Science as a Vocation. What should emerge from the text is a reconstruction of the possibility, entertained and finally rejected by these authors, that an aesthetic justification of persons' labours might provide a liberating alternative to the scientific rationalism that is modernity. Comparisons between the works of Max Weber and Karl Marx are rife in social science literature, 2 yet there seems to be little consensus, and instead much controversy, concerning the exact nature of their analytical relationship. Few students of the social sciences are incapable of rehearsing upon command the standard interpretation of The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, viz., that Weber attests in the essay to the independent force of religious ideas on social and economic development in the West and thereby turns an historical materialist account of the rise of capitalism on its head. To be sure, if one is sufficiently pressured, one will modify this formulation to accommodate Weber's conspicuous rejoinder that his thought not be associated with any school of one-sided idealism or spiritual determinism. Beyond this level of analysis, however, the literature includes a wide array of conflicting interpretations, some of the more tendentious conclusions from which are as follows: *A number of persons have helped me bring this paper to fruition, but I would particularly like to thank Paul Thomas for his instruction and support throughout the writing process as well as Reinhard Bendix and Tracy B. Strong for their sustaining influences. This content downloaded from 157.55.39.127 on Wed, 29 Jun 2016 05:51:02 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 130 BERKELEY JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY -that Weber is the bourgeois Marx3 -that Weber puts an end to ideology4 -that Weberian sociology has achieved an ideological success far beyond anything warranted in Weber's own stated position5 -that Weber starts out as a Marxist and ends up as a Nietzschean6 -that Marx converts, whereas Weber disillusions7 -that the whole of Weber's thesis fits Marxism without" @default.
- W632328669 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W632328669 creator A5033984439 @default.
- W632328669 date "1982-01-01" @default.
- W632328669 modified "2023-09-22" @default.
- W632328669 title "Marxism as Artwork: Weber and Lukács in Heidelberg, 1912-1914" @default.
- W632328669 cites W146591166 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1480877497 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1493113839 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1503946872 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1515922720 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1523625620 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1529085066 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1541454112 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1547318789 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1547638630 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1601188899 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1745497042 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1983820676 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1986592775 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1990405763 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1994995095 @default.
- W632328669 cites W1995312609 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2000178893 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2014379757 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2021123363 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2026145369 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2040894080 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2049232791 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2054530142 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2058593638 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2059959921 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2073200417 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2082378590 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2091822548 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2123197406 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2139444829 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2140409505 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2150613668 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2160616163 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2270333552 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2312766430 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2312833514 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2315608795 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2320224906 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2320799495 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2320989456 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2321935186 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2329401673 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2330044334 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2332280608 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2332802364 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2335472001 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2570750360 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2614168992 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2771080776 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2802457175 @default.
- W632328669 cites W3138215859 @default.
- W632328669 cites W377960647 @default.
- W632328669 cites W388244049 @default.
- W632328669 cites W577086413 @default.
- W632328669 cites W634522669 @default.
- W632328669 cites W2741875298 @default.
- W632328669 hasPublicationYear "1982" @default.
- W632328669 type Work @default.
- W632328669 sameAs 632328669 @default.
- W632328669 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W632328669 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W632328669 hasAuthorship W632328669A5033984439 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C144218379 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C180903884 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C201089411 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C2778682666 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C2779658751 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C514928085 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C517673595 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C527412718 @default.
- W632328669 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C107038049 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C111472728 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C138885662 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C144024400 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C144218379 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C17744445 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C180903884 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C199539241 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C201089411 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C2778682666 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C2779658751 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C41895202 @default.
- W632328669 hasConceptScore W632328669C514928085 @default.