Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W69488521> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W69488521 abstract "Extensive literatures exist on the epistemology of testimony, memory, and perception, but for the most part these literatures do not systematically consider the extent of the analogies between the three epistemic sources. A number of the same problems reappear in all three literatures, however. Dealing simultaneously with all three sources and making a careful accounting of the analogies and disanalogies between them should therefore avoid unnecessary duplication of effort. Other than limits on the scope of which memorially- and testimonially-based beliefs should be included in the Parity Thesis, I argue that most of the disanalogies that different philosophers have proffered between the sources do not mark distinctions among the universes of possible testimonially-, memorially-, and perceptually-based beliefs regarding the explanation of those beliefs' epistemic status. I first criticize the suggestion that perception is a generative epistemic source, while testimony and memory are not; I propose and defend counterexamples in which testimony and memory produce new beliefs. Next, I criticize a variety of distinctions that have been drawn between testimony and perception, taken chiefly from the reductionist-antireductionist literature on testimony. I criticize the suggestion that the conceptualization of content and the transparency of experience affect the epistemologies of testimony and perception in different ways. Regarding memory and testimony, I advocate modeling testimony on the legal relationship of a principal and an agent, arguing that law's apparatus used to analyze such situations suggests that using others' epistemic services in testimony will supply the same epistemic benefits and burdens as if we had performed those epistemic tasks personally and then relied only on memory. I apply this analysis to the transmission of defeaters in testimony. I argue that memory does feature the epistemic equivalent of a perceptual image and that both perceptually- and memorially-based beliefs can concern either the past or the present. Finally, I construct a set of six transformations that turn individual possible instances of perceptually-, memorially-, or testimonially-based beliefs into individual possible instances of the other two types of beliefs without changing the structure of those beliefs' epistemologies." @default.
- W69488521 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W69488521 creator A5048123762 @default.
- W69488521 date "2006-01-01" @default.
- W69488521 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W69488521 title "The Epistemic Parity of Testimony, Memory, and Perception" @default.
- W69488521 cites W113377690 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1495254462 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1519243542 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1522345020 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1545809291 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1594646173 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1844227983 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1952418409 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1984052764 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1993007616 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1994381356 @default.
- W69488521 cites W1994635058 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2009127896 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2017050501 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2020797890 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2021499106 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2033446545 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2035834232 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2053715566 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2061671637 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2063616077 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2068530826 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2072729203 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2077352067 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2150142674 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2166606808 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2171734057 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2179104041 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2196342840 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2246269584 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2276275925 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2328957477 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2330661897 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2334554744 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2604306431 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2727371524 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2795441816 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2795463046 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2937687726 @default.
- W69488521 cites W3135212331 @default.
- W69488521 cites W3139675874 @default.
- W69488521 cites W321892531 @default.
- W69488521 cites W361977554 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4214881911 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4230753412 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4231726226 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4232758249 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4233020254 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4234821997 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4234973058 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4235294812 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4236205108 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4237472471 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4238409248 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4239232206 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4240761142 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4242025012 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4242305198 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4242774779 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4242914487 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4243749950 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4243853979 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4245141324 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4245645376 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4245788097 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4246765332 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4248451280 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4248488102 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4248946683 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4249908124 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4252591847 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4254144201 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4254644067 @default.
- W69488521 cites W4302041990 @default.
- W69488521 cites W580133133 @default.
- W69488521 cites W606819821 @default.
- W69488521 cites W7102398 @default.
- W69488521 cites W80955462 @default.
- W69488521 cites W85144652 @default.
- W69488521 cites W857754 @default.
- W69488521 cites W969018012 @default.
- W69488521 cites W2327131947 @default.
- W69488521 doi "https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1005782" @default.
- W69488521 hasPublicationYear "2006" @default.
- W69488521 type Work @default.
- W69488521 sameAs 69488521 @default.
- W69488521 citedByCount "5" @default.
- W69488521 countsByYear W694885212015 @default.
- W69488521 countsByYear W694885212020 @default.
- W69488521 countsByYear W694885212022 @default.
- W69488521 countsByYear W694885212023 @default.
- W69488521 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W69488521 hasAuthorship W69488521A5048123762 @default.
- W69488521 hasConcept C111472728 @default.