Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W76138743> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W76138743 startingPage "128" @default.
- W76138743 abstract "INTRODUCTION Citizen participation in local government has been advocated as a way to enhance communication between government and citizens, build public support for local government goals, and develop public trust in government (Wang, 2001). However, research has shown increased citizen input can alternatively lead to a variety of perceived negative consequences such as increased staff work load, additional resource allocation, increased levels of public scrutiny, negative media coverage and increased levels of apathy or distrust of government (Callahan, 2002). Thus not all participation efforts are equal in terms of their impact or outcomes. In considering the nature and scope of citizen participation, it is imperative to have some basis for understanding what constitutes effectiveness. Arguments in favor of citizen participation are rooted in normative theory, and as a result, discussions of what constitutes participation are likewise normatively-based. Yet we should be equally (if not more) concerned with how the stakeholders of participation--practitioners, elected officials, and citizens--understand effective citizen participation. This article advances our understanding of citizen participation efforts in local government by offering a multi-dimensional conceptualization of effective citizen participation as articulated by those most directly involved in the process: elected officials, local government staff, and citizens. Perceptions of citizen participation in the local government budget process were captured through a series of forty telephone interviews in four cities across North Carolina. In addition to asking what key stakeholder groups mean by citizen participation, we also explore where these understandings converge and diverge. In other words, we examine to what extent expectations among the groups are different or similar. FRAMING CITIZEN PARTICIPATION Citizen participation in government is fundamental, as is the dispute over the extent and means participation. Daniel P. Monyihan (1969) argued that the maximum feasible participation goals of early anti-poverty efforts had actually resulted in maximum feasible misunderstanding. The experience of Community Action Programs in the 1960s and the controversy over how to define and implement the idea of participation by social program recipients led to a series of influential articles debating the basis for participation, which was widely interpreted at the time as a way to provide empowerment for low-income or minority populations (see, for example, Strange, 1972; Krause, 1968; Van Til & Van Til, 1970). Current debates are no longer focused on class and power discussions prevalent in the 1960s and 1970s. In fact, there seems to be widespread agreement in the field of public administration, as well as popular support for, the idea of creating more avenues to develop and foster citizen participation in local government (King, Feltey, & Susel, 1998; Bingham, Nabatchi, & O'Leary, 2005). There are now a multitude of resources available for designing citizen participation processes. (1) There is also a substantial amount written on civic attitudes toward government decisionmaking, rife with assumptions that participatory processes have the power to change these attitudes (Gastil and Levine, 2005). Of course the idea of public participation is appealing, but perhaps more complicated than we imagine. Skelcher (2007) suggests we argue for democratic processes often without understanding if they actually improve public service performance. However, to understand if democratic processes actually improve public service performance, we need to define what we mean by improving performance; we need a definition of effectiveness. We find that a number of researchers are trying to define effectiveness, but none take their cue from stakeholders within the process itself. Sherry Arnstein's classic ladder of citizen participation (1969) shapes much of discussion of participatory processes. …" @default.
- W76138743 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W76138743 creator A5017706441 @default.
- W76138743 creator A5076023861 @default.
- W76138743 creator A5085235962 @default.
- W76138743 date "2011-03-22" @default.
- W76138743 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W76138743 title "What Constitutes Effective Citizen Participation in Local Government? Views from City Stakeholders" @default.
- W76138743 cites W1487155075 @default.
- W76138743 cites W1978313620 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2007211599 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2008251417 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2011397672 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2027402365 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2036446422 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2062395994 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2063018056 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2124672863 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2125626633 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2131574185 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2131597270 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2151541208 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2313439621 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2318263026 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2329569062 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2332405336 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2412160207 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2772104422 @default.
- W76138743 cites W2951383468 @default.
- W76138743 cites W3121956775 @default.
- W76138743 cites W3125586858 @default.
- W76138743 cites W602528938 @default.
- W76138743 cites W644155216 @default.
- W76138743 cites W656630734 @default.
- W76138743 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W76138743 type Work @default.
- W76138743 sameAs 76138743 @default.
- W76138743 citedByCount "14" @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432013 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432014 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432015 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432017 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432018 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432019 @default.
- W76138743 countsByYear W761387432020 @default.
- W76138743 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W76138743 hasAuthorship W76138743A5017706441 @default.
- W76138743 hasAuthorship W76138743A5076023861 @default.
- W76138743 hasAuthorship W76138743A5085235962 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C201305675 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C2776050585 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C2777976496 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C2778137410 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C2778321746 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C2778719706 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C3116431 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C39549134 @default.
- W76138743 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C138885662 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C144024400 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C17744445 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C199539241 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C201305675 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C2776050585 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C2777976496 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C2778137410 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C2778321746 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C2778719706 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C3116431 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C39549134 @default.
- W76138743 hasConceptScore W76138743C41895202 @default.
- W76138743 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W76138743 hasLocation W761387431 @default.
- W76138743 hasOpenAccess W76138743 @default.
- W76138743 hasPrimaryLocation W761387431 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W1569941290 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W1593204202 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W1969366758 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W1975659308 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2006328925 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2008251417 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2019160725 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2065800536 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2076771278 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2124672863 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2140150066 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2180141121 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2332358149 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2332405336 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2496930187 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W250913812 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2600155761 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W2935883200 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W3203955907 @default.
- W76138743 hasRelatedWork W5954820 @default.