FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W815703313> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W815703313 abstract "Being Human is a masterful argument for the value and necessity of the human sciences and of their history. In a reflexive dialogue with a long Continental tradition, from Giambattista Vico to Hans-Georg Gadamer, Smith makes a case for the human sciences qua sciences proper. This requires some qualification for the English reader, to whom ‘science’ normally means ‘natural science’, whilst Smith employs it in the non-disciplinary sense of the original scientia. In a nutshell, the argument is that human sciences are sciences just as much as the natural ones, that they are defined by different purposes – not objects or methods – and that they are constitutively historical and moral. The human sciences are, in principle as in practice, irreducible to the natural ones – indeed, the opposite argument emerges throughout the book. Their legitimacy is grounded on their intrinsically reflexive character – as opposed to the extrinsic ‘reflectivity’ of the natural sciences – that expresses itself in the specificity of their object (the concrete, historical making of being human) and in their dialogical, hermeneutic approach. There is no place out of history. Thus, materialistic and naturalistic claims to ‘exclusive access’ (p. 7), to knowledge about what is human, are simply declared as ‘mistaken’, on grounds that being human is not about possessing a nature, rather it is a reflexive act engaging the past, present and future in a moral process of self-formation. ‘Human’, Smith argues, is a moral category, defined in and by its making. That is why the human sciences do not, and cannot, constitute a disciplinary form of knowledge, but ‘[create] a social space where disciplines seek to co-operate’ (p. 213). All sciences that have a bearing on being human can be human sciences, provided that their own historicity is acknowledged, and with it, the necessity of multiple perspectives on being human.Being Human can be read as an argument for historical science as the pinnacle of knowledge, the science of all sciences in their concrete becoming. Smith seeks to avoid this by constant reference to a multiplicity of legitimate knowledges, serving different contingent purposes. This leads to some complications. First, the problem of the epistemological relations among the sciences: one cannot see how the human sciences, in this context, can ever be open to any input from the natural sciences. ‘Indeed, knowledge of nature needs reinterpretation in the light of knowledge of people, not vice versa’ (p. 13). Much as the multiplicity of the approaches is stressed, again, as inherent to the concept of human sciences, a hierarchy of knowledge unfolds through the book, reminiscent of Croce’s absolute historicism (which Smith does not address). Second, the reference to different values and interests grounding the multiplicity of perspectives opens up a related, if different problem: that of the concrete historical relations of the natural and human sciences. Smith does not address this issue systematically, although at all critical points but one he makes enlightening references to the institutional and political dimensions of these boundary disputes. Where he fails to provide this contextualisation is in relation to the present. The Humboldtian university, which provided the blueprint for the disciplinary and professional organisation of knowledge, was consubstantial to the ideal of Bildung. That model has come to a crisis: the scientific disciplines are dissolving into interdisciplinary fields, while the criteria of productivity and significance of the natural sciences, together with their organisation of labour, are being extended to all education and knowledge production. The historical sciences of the human, therefore, find themselves logically superordinate, for the dignity of their object and their bearing at once theoretical and moral, but actually subordinate, being evaluated on grounds they cannot share.Smith makes a brave and timely move in showing that the sciences of being human are logically sound and, moreover, epistemologically and morally necessary as sciences of anthropopoiesis, generation of meaning and value. But the fact that all sciences have a value-based foundation says nothing about the relative force of these values, and of their concrete, ideal and political effects. ‘Natural’, we must not forget, is as moral a category as ‘human’, and a most powerful one nowadays." @default.
• W815703313 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W815703313 creator A5022044083 @default.
• W815703313 date "2011-10-01" @default.
• W815703313 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
• W815703313 title "Roger Smith, Being Human: Historical Knowledge and the Creation of Human Nature (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2007), pp. viii + 288, £25.00, hardback, ISBN: 978-0-7190-7498-1." @default.
• W815703313 doi "https://doi.org/10.1017/s0025727300005238" @default.
• W815703313 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/3199655" @default.
• W815703313 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
• W815703313 type Work @default.
• W815703313 sameAs 815703313 @default.
• W815703313 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W815703313 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W815703313 hasAuthorship W815703313A5022044083 @default.
• W815703313 hasBestOaLocation W8157033131 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C10646191 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C119857082 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C13200473 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C144218379 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C193235544 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C198293453 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C2776291640 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C2776608160 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C2781238097 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C36289849 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W815703313 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C10646191 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C111472728 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C119857082 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C13200473 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C138885662 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C144024400 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C144218379 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C166957645 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C185592680 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C193235544 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C198293453 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C2776291640 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C2776608160 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C2781238097 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C36289849 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C41008148 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C41895202 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C55493867 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C95457728 @default.
• W815703313 hasConceptScore W815703313C98184364 @default.
• W815703313 hasLocation W8157033131 @default.
• W815703313 hasOpenAccess W815703313 @default.
• W815703313 hasPrimaryLocation W8157033131 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W106786507 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W1557934282 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W1560266397 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W1904355000 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2016890976 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2058163158 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2303510627 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2320311541 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2501974415 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W264673651 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2914502284 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W2985492780 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W3027077770 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W3082029958 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W3122827724 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W3171476618 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W321725386 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W92376483 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W97165022 @default.
• W815703313 hasRelatedWork W980399715 @default.
• W815703313 isParatext "false" @default.
• W815703313 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W815703313 magId "815703313" @default.
• W815703313 workType "article" @default.