Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W81571031> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W81571031 abstract "The impetus for this enquiry came from two experiences with an Aboriginal Other, which prompted the initial research questions: “Why does the existence of an Aboriginal Other threaten a white sense of belonging?” and; “What are the mechanisms and purposes of aggression towards, or exclusion of, that which represents otherness in the Australian context?” In the introductory chapters, the author’s experiences at Lake Mungo and Legend Rock are presented as case studies to illustrate Wittgenstein’s (1953/1968) concept of the ways that subject positions are constructed through language games and hegemonic discourses. Psychodynamic theories of identity formation have been applied to the analysis of these cases to argue that the unconscious construction of Australia as a good, white and Christian nation has acted to overwrite Aboriginal perspectives and to position Aboriginal people at the margins of society. In Chapter One the case of Lake Mungo was presented to illustrate the ways that language games function as cultural frames, through which all experience is filtered. As well, Buhler’s (1934/1990) conception of the deictic and symbolic fields, and the role of the proper noun in allowing or disallowing individuals to occupy a position in the symbolic order as subjective agents was discussed. Here, a relationship between cultural framing and the construction of hegemonic discourses which act to position all that is Other outside positions of enunciation was posited. This was followed by a brief exploration of the concept that the lives of Aboriginal people are organized according to an ontological position that differs in fundamental ways from the world view of the white mainstream. Specifically, it was argued that the social realities of Aboriginal people are embedded within their relation to land and the kinship obligations associated with belonging to a particular community in a particular place. A series of hypothetical indices of difference, based on Margaret Bain’s (1992) research into a semi-remote Aboriginal community at Finke, in Central Australia, was presented. The centrality of whiteness as an organizing principle in Australia was illustrated by Barton’s (1901) “A White Australia” speech, made at the time of Federation. In the ensuing investigation of the way that the dominant culture has constructed an ideal image of the typical Australian, it was suggested that white Australians identify with a mythical Good Australia though white discourses of enlightened nation building and Empire, in which Aboriginal culture has been “mapped and managed” into a museum context and Aboriginal people have been rendered as “metonymically frozen into an extinct past” (Hemming, 2003, pp. 1-3). In Chapter Two, a case study approach, based on Freud’s model of analysis as an archaeology of the present, was used to explore the mechanisms behind the occlusion of Aboriginality as a presence in the case of Legend Rock. The Freudian (1919) concept of the uncanny was critical to the investigation of the particular anxieties around belonging that are evoked for white Australians when confronted with the unfamiliar Aboriginal presence in familiar spaces. In this section of the thesis, Gelder and Jacob’s (1999) characterization of the overturning of the legal fiction of terra nullius after Mabo as the return of the repressed was discussed. In Chapter Three, the rationale for using a case study approach to address the guiding hypothesis and the propositions to be investigated in the current study are outlined. Chapter Four introduces Lacan’s (1949/2002) conceptualization of the mirror stage, during which identifications are formed and the ego, or “I” is first recognized, as well as Klein’s (1937/1964) theory of primitive defence mechanisms. The ideas of these clinicians were used to explore the function of the Other in both normal development and in pathological states. This literature was then applied to an investigation of the process of othering as it has manifested in the Australian context in more general terms. Rutherford’s (2000) thesis: that an Australian ego-ideal has been based on the identification with a mythical being-without-lack, provided a starting point for analysis of the ways that white Australia has constructed a veil around cultural difference in order to defend against acknowledging the fact that Aboriginal peoples have been profoundly damaged by the practices and processes of colonization, and that these practices and processes continue to damage current generations of Aboriginal people. In Chapter Five, it was argued that, after Mabo, white Australians have had no choice but to adopt one of two defensive positions with respect to Aboriginal Australia. Following Money-Kyrle’s (1951) reading of Klein, these positions were nominated as being characterized by either persecutory or depressive guilt. The rejection of the Aboriginal story of Legend Rock was posited as representing the persecutory position, which was discussed in terms of the phenomenon of the rise of Pauline Hanson and One Nation. It was argued that the denial of Aboriginal rights, and attacks on Aboriginal people as the recipients of special treatment, could be explained as representing the manic defence of a large minority of the white mainstream in response to perceived threats to identifications with the Good Australia evoked by the recognition of Native Title. As Klein has explained, the manic defence is driven by anxiety and functions through the primitive psychological process of splitting, whereby internalized good (ego syntonic) objects are retained and internalized bad (ego dystonic) objects are projected onto the scapegoated Other. In the case of One Nation, Aboriginal people were represented as “greedy” people who wanted to take away “our backyards”. By contrast, it was argued that many white Australians had adopted the more difficult depressive position, which was best exemplified by Paul Keating’s (1993) Redfern Park Speech. The processes of splitting and projection that characterize the persecutory position enable us to repress the knowledge that we have inflicted harm, and thereby escape feelings of guilt. Depressive guilt, on the other hand, is associated with the painful awareness that harm has been done and a desire to make reparation to the damaged psychic object. This desire was manifest in the emergence of grass roots movements, such as Australians for Reconciliation, comprised mainly of white Australians, who organized their own responses to the stance taken by Pauline Hanson’s One Nation Party. Australians who wished to amend past wrongs were frustrated by the inertia of the Wik debate, the failed referendum for a republic, the Treaty debate, and the dismantling of the Aboriginal Tent Embassy in Canberra. Ordinary citizens walked over bridges and contributed to the Sea of Hands in their tens of thousands to show their solidarity with Aboriginal people. The “Sorry” books were in answer to the Howard administration’s steadfast refusal to make an apology and offer compensation to the Stolen Generations, as had been recommended by Wilson and Dodson’s (1997) Bringing them Home Report. Chapter Six outlined the epistemological and methodological framework within which the research was conducted. In this section, the ethics of conducting research with indigenous communities has been presented, and the reasons for adopting a critical approach to psychological research are explained. The primary data from the interviews was presented in Chapters Seven, Eight and Nine. Data was organized into sections according to the main themes that were raised by the indigenous participants, accompanied by relevant commentary from the non-indigenous contributors. The analysis of the emergent themes has been presented alongside the data within each section. In Chapter Seven, the guiding hypothesis that Bain’s (1992) indices of difference would be salient for a cohort of Aboriginal people living in urban and regional environments was partially supported. The Aboriginal participants’ subjective experience of their Aboriginal identity was explored In Chapter Eight. In Chapter Nine, Lacan’s concept that the unconscious is structured like a language, together with his emphasis on the role of metaphor in creating the illusion of fixed meanings, was used to investigate how Aboriginal narratives of identity have been influenced by representations of Aboriginality in both mainstream and indigenous communities. In Chapter Ten, a summary of findings, conclusions and recommendations has been presented." @default.
- W81571031 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W81571031 creator A5002071813 @default.
- W81571031 date "2007-01-01" @default.
- W81571031 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W81571031 title "Between surfaces: a psychodynamic approach to cultural identity, cultural difference and reconciliation in Australia" @default.
- W81571031 cites W105084895 @default.
- W81571031 cites W123366752 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1481609295 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1486145806 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1491182911 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1494632870 @default.
- W81571031 cites W149730463 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1506150625 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1507453575 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1517519170 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1521264059 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1527311855 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1527968558 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1530189020 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1531696527 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1538247143 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1541164384 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1542535563 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1543187522 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1545361542 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1546641058 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1549075571 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1551252481 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1555360923 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1557791941 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1558509633 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1558687066 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1565693361 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1569948371 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1570218391 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1572265179 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1573028790 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1573152930 @default.
- W81571031 cites W158798662 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1590567639 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1597183254 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1597737301 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1601941206 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1602905321 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1605251301 @default.
- W81571031 cites W160636725 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1614549126 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1637437975 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1658908529 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1664990607 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1679875037 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1717383561 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1717643653 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1720881856 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1742365845 @default.
- W81571031 cites W180021731 @default.
- W81571031 cites W190124971 @default.
- W81571031 cites W191587287 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1944150654 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1966404444 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1968624883 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1969840809 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1972088018 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1972159854 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1972513460 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1978457872 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1979648634 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1984491204 @default.
- W81571031 cites W1995900918 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2002658673 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2003612898 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2004184632 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2005815000 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2005974278 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2012304555 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2016435021 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2018346418 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2019680423 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2022733107 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2022818679 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2029275198 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2029648951 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2030417522 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2033952602 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2039472325 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2040428046 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2040789382 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2041289345 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2041886104 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2042284792 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2044111625 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2044223458 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2044950274 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2045403074 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2050657009 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2050890080 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2059176358 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2066095696 @default.
- W81571031 cites W2070679881 @default.