Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W906206883> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W906206883 endingPage "8933" @default.
- W906206883 startingPage "8922" @default.
- W906206883 abstract "The 298.15 K formation enthalpies of 38 radicals with molecular formula CxHyOz have been computed via the atomization procedure using the five title methods. The computed formation enthalpies are then benchmarked against the values recommended in the Active Thermochemical Tables (ATcT). The accuracy of the methods have been interpreted in terms of descriptive statistics, including the mean-signed error, mean-unsigned error, maximum average deviation, 2σ uncertainties, and 2×root-mean-square-deviations (2RMSD). The results highlight the following rank order of accuracy for the methods studied G4 > G3 > W1BD > CBS-APNO > CBS-QB3. The findings of this work are also considered in light of a recent companion study, which took an identical approach to quantifying the accuracies of these methods for 48 closed-shell singlet CxHyOz compounds. A similar order of accuracies and precisions were observed therein: G3 > G4 > W1BD > CBS-APNO > CBS-QB3. Both studies highlight systematic biases/deviations from the ATcT for the methods investigated, which are discussed in some detail, with methods having clear tendencies to over- or underpredict the recommended formation enthalpies for radical and/or closed-shell CxHyOz compounds. We show that one can improve the accuracy of their computation, and simultaneously reduce the uncertainty, by taking unweighted average formation enthalpies from various combinations of methods used. The reader should note that the statistical analyses preceding these conclusions also highlight that these error cancellation effects are unique for closed-shell and radical species. By extension, these error-cancellation effects can be expected to be different for various homologous series and chemical functionalities and their closed- and open-shell subgroups. Hence, further benchmarking studies are advised for other homologous series, such that the scientists and engineers (e.g., combustion/atmospheric/astrochemical) who frequently use these methods can assign reasonable uncertainties to their computations, while simultaneously optimizing their computational costs. For CxHyOz compounds, a combination of the CBS-APNO/G3/G4 methods is shown to be quite powerful when the atomization method is employed and is capable of reproducing the ATcT to within near-chemical-accuracy, with 2RMSD (≈95% confidence interval) values of 0.0 ± 4.34 kJ mol(-1) computed for CxHyOz radicals, 0.0 ± 4.22 kJ mol(-1) for closed-shell CxHyOz compounds, with a total uncertainty of 0.0 ± 4.27 kJ mol(-1) subsequently computed considering all 85 CxHyOz compounds. Given the performance of these methods for determination of formation enthalpies when the atomization procedure is employed, we expect isodesmic reactions involving these methods to be capable of achieving chemical accuracy, as illustrated for the case of the tert-butyl radical. We also highlight that there is still disagreement between experiment and theory for this radical, despite its significance in gas-phase chemistry. Kineticists, thermodynamicists, and chemical kinetic modellers alike are warned that the popular CBS-QB3 method is found to have particularly poor performance, with a computed 2RMSD of 0.0 ± 12.51 kJ mol(-1), indicating that one should not apply this method in isolation for formation enthalpy determination unless other error-cancellation strategies are employed." @default.
- W906206883 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W906206883 creator A5034918586 @default.
- W906206883 creator A5058330697 @default.
- W906206883 date "2015-08-06" @default.
- W906206883 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W906206883 title "Benchmarking Compound Methods (CBS-QB3, CBS-APNO, G3, G4, W1BD) against the Active Thermochemical Tables: Formation Enthalpies of Radicals" @default.
- W906206883 cites W1966435513 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1975702269 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1976127374 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1976774792 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1991647825 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1994372519 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1994917514 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1997903375 @default.
- W906206883 cites W1998725642 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2001199058 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2001781331 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2012982996 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2021095103 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2026436920 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2028388745 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2040195084 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2046462722 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2048382000 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2069167345 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2075711588 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2075730114 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2094075860 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2095948981 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2101698639 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2104631894 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2165131446 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2312607100 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2314186594 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2316431757 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2328937788 @default.
- W906206883 cites W2333113984 @default.
- W906206883 cites W3100859786 @default.
- W906206883 cites W3104541550 @default.
- W906206883 doi "https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpca.5b05448" @default.
- W906206883 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26171842" @default.
- W906206883 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W906206883 type Work @default.
- W906206883 sameAs 906206883 @default.
- W906206883 citedByCount "120" @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832015 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832016 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832017 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832018 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832019 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832020 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832021 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832022 @default.
- W906206883 countsByYear W9062068832023 @default.
- W906206883 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W906206883 hasAuthorship W906206883A5034918586 @default.
- W906206883 hasAuthorship W906206883A5058330697 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C139066938 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C147368240 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C147597530 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C147789679 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C178790620 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C22679943 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C37649677 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C59801894 @default.
- W906206883 hasConcept C97355855 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C105795698 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C121332964 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C139066938 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C147368240 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C147597530 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C147789679 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C178790620 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C185592680 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C22679943 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C33923547 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C37649677 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C59801894 @default.
- W906206883 hasConceptScore W906206883C97355855 @default.
- W906206883 hasIssue "33" @default.
- W906206883 hasLocation W9062068831 @default.
- W906206883 hasLocation W9062068832 @default.
- W906206883 hasOpenAccess W906206883 @default.
- W906206883 hasPrimaryLocation W9062068831 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W1963918843 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2018698677 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2022345764 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2025702746 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2041093077 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2063238192 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2077797342 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2080867589 @default.
- W906206883 hasRelatedWork W2362554202 @default.